Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another


Supreme Court Nixes Deal Over Illegal Outpost

Migron to disappear by August 1, barring further gov’t action, noncompliance

Print Email
Migron today.6(Menahem Kahana/AFP/Getty Images)

Yet again, defenders of Israel’s democratic character may point to its judicial system, and especially the Supreme Court, as a bulwark for the rule of law. Last summer, the Supreme Court, hearing a petition brought with the help of the left-wing group Peace Now, ruled that Migron—a settlement, or “outpost,” near Ramallah in the West Bank that is considered illegal even under Israeli law and was built in 1999 without government permission on land that seems to be owned by certain Palestinians—had to be taken down and its residents relocated by the end of this month. The Israeli government—which is pro-settlements, though arguably has legitimate interests in minimizing discord—recently offered an apparently extralegal compromise to Migron’s 50 families: It would build legal (or “legal,” if you’re much of the international community) housing for them nearby and they would be forced to move in 2015. Deal, the settlers said.

No deal, the Supreme Court replied yesterday. Granting a four-month extension due to the hubbub, the court ordered the settlers moved by Aug. 1. “This is a necessary component of the rule of law to which all are subject as part of Israel’s values as a Jewish and democratic state,” its opinion read.

During last week’s arguments, one of the three judges who joined the unanimous ruling was more blunt: “You say the outpost will move in three years, but I know this type of behavior. Three years will inevitably turn into eight.”

Prime Minister Netanyahu has said the government will abide by the ruling. There does appear, however, a chance for the Knesset to step in. As it is, however, the government currently plans to move the settlers to mobile homes in a nearby settlement within 60 days and go from there.

I think sympathy for the settlers is perfectly acceptable, even if they are, as seems likely, true believers. Having one’s life uprooted is no easy thing. The mistake was the government’s for allowing the settlement to be built; rebuilt in 2001; and not torn down, as it was supposed to be, in 2003 (plans for Gaza disengagement put the kibosh on that), or during subsequent years. But sympathy can’t get in the way of justice, and justice demands that Migron disappear. We should be grateful the Israeli Supreme Court sees it that way and hope that everybody else complies.

Israel’s Top Court Orders Settlers to Leave Outpost [NYT]
A History of the West Bank Outpost of Migron [Haaretz]
Netanyahu: Government Will Abide by High Court Ruling on Migron [Arutz Sheva]
Top Official Says Knesset Could Call Emergency Meet Over High Court’s Ruling on Migron [Haaretz]

Print Email
Sara G. says:

From medical care to settlements, to social services, in Israel, he who shouts loudest, prevails. The government continuously makes compromises to appease those who break the law but cry out loud. The Israeli government allows law breakers to set the agenda where the law and the government should be supreme.
It isn’t only the Israeli government which is at fault in Migron, it is the settlers who say the law is wrong, the court is wrong, that they are right, and their rights are uber alles. Now they promise a battle.
The bile rises watching benny begin double-speak, the settlers speaking about issues which are no longer on the table, the derogatory way they speak of supreme court justices. The court is right, they will drag it out forever.
Israel is either a state with laws which are enforced, or it is a state ruled by hooligans and knesset members who shamelessly are scheming to get around court orders.


Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Supreme Court Nixes Deal Over Illegal Outpost

Migron to disappear by August 1, barring further gov’t action, noncompliance

More on Tablet:

Why Russia is No Place to Be Charlie

By Vladislav Davidzon — Moscow activists face jail as Kremlin allows counter-protest in Chechnya