Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

Israel’s Starving Survivors

One in five Holocaust survivors in Israel goes hungry. We must fix this shame right away.

Print Email
During a protest next to the prime minister’s office in Jerusalem on August 5, 2007, an Israeli survivor of the Holocaust adjusts his cap, with a sticker that reads in Hebrew: “Holocaust and Shame.” (Emilio Morenatti/AP)
Related Content

Boldface Aid for Shoah Victims

Blossom director Zane Buzby offers financial support to a group of tragically overlooked Holocaust survivors

Do We Still Need Yom HaShoah?

The commemorative day is confusing and arbitrary. Let’s find a more meaningful alternative.

Survivor

There are thousands of destitute Holocaust survivors living in the New York area

Esther Frank survived Theresienstadt and Auschwitz. After the war, she moved to Israel, eventually settling in a small apartment in Petach Tikva. She worked hard her entire life, but could hardly save any money. As old age began creeping up on her, Frank found herself struggling to live on the meager pension paid to her by the state, NIS 2,000, or approximately $550, per month. For years, she walked around in clunky men’s shoes, a size too big; for 40 shekels, they were an unbeatable deal. She desperately needed a hearing aid but, not being able to afford one, continued to spend most of her days sitting alone on her small, brown couch, silent, disconnected from the world. She couldn’t even hear the burglar who sneaked in to her house, knowing that she was old and defenseless. By the time she noticed him, it was too late. There was nothing she could do. He picked up her wallet and stole 86 shekels. It was everything Frank had left. Shaken, she took to locking her front door, a jarring change after a life of leaving it wide open to welcome in friends and neighbors. Two days later, she fell. Unable to call for help, her door locked, she just lay there for hours until she finally managed to get up and reach the phone. In 2007, an Israeli television crew interviewed Frank. The piece made many people cry, and donations started pouring in. Frank could now afford a hearing aid. She was fitted for one, and was thrilled when it was finally put in. She died a few days later.

According to a survey released last week by the Foundation for the Benefit of Holocaust Victims in Israel, 37 Holocaust survivors living in the Jewish state pass away every day. That’s more than a thousand people a month. And as the survey revealed, too many of them live, like Esther Frank, in conditions of abject poverty. One out of five survivors, for example, admitted to having had to forgo food at least once due to lack of funds, and 14 percent said that their financial situation led them to give up on purchasing necessary medicine. A quarter of the survivors replied that they were struggling with poverty, and a third had applied to the foundation, seeking financial aid. The overwhelming majority—more than two-thirds—reported monthly incomes no larger than NIS 3,000, or $830. The median salary in Israel is around $1,550.

In part, bureaucracy’s to blame for this negligence. No fewer than seven different government ministries are entrusted with providing basic services to the 192,000 Holocaust survivors currently living in Israel, and a slew of nonprofit organizations all work to supply them with anything from food to medical services. But lacking a single organized framework and a clear hierarchy, many of the efforts overlap, and most survivors remain uninformed of their basic rights. Esther Frank, for example, was eligible to additional benefits, but neither she nor the Social Security representatives with whom she was in touch had any idea. By the time someone noticed her, it was too late.

And time, the foundation in Israel said in a statement, is running out. “We’re facing a critical window that’s closing on us,” said an official statement. “In five years, the demographic balance will change in a way that would make aid to survivors unnecessary, as there will be more of them dying than living and in need of assistance.”

Walking around his neighborhood in Be’er Sheva last winter, a university student named Ido Doav saw a small elderly woman shivering in the cold. It was raining, and the woman turned to Doav, told him she was very tired, and asked for his help climbing the stairs to her apartment. As Doav took her arm, he noticed the faint inky numbers, marking her as a Holocaust survivor. When he opened the door to her apartment, he was shocked: Mice were running around freely, the floor was smeared with feces, and every surface was covered with years’ worth of grime. Doav called a few of his friends, and together they spent hours scrubbing the woman’s apartment. “I’ve never done anyone any harm,” the woman, who preferred to remain nameless, told a television crew that arrived to interview her. “I would at least like for my home to be clean.”

A clean home, a warm meal, medicine, a hearing aid, comfortable shoes—none of these are luxuries. They are basic, fundamental rights. And they’re even more basic, more fundamental when the recipients in question are survivors of the Shoah living in the Jewish state. It is Israel’s duty, of course, to rectify this injustice, but it is also up to Jews anywhere to see to it that this is done right away. I know that effective charitable giving is a complicated matter. I realize there are complicated organizational question at play. But I don’t care. At the risk of sounding simplistic or bombastic or overly sentimental, every dollar, every shekel, anyone anywhere gives to any Jewish organization is rendered meaningless by the rumbling stomach of a single elderly survivor of the Holocaust. If you do anything today to mark Yom HaShoah—light a candle, go to a film, even share this article—make this call to action part of it.

***

Like this article? Sign up for our Daily Digest to get Tablet Magazine’s new content in your inbox each morning.

Print Email
Rebecca K. says:

I think that we need to do something more than pass on “a call to action.” Take action: provide a meal, clean a home, give a ride to a doctor’s appointment–something concrete–to the survivors around us. Don’t wait for the government to do something.

Let’s stop the demagoguery and solve the problem. Israel actually has good policies in place to support the elderly, (For instance home visits by an aid giver 3X per work for week) but these people have to be reached.

this is truly a disgrace the money Israel has received in their name. And they’re going hungry

Yehuda Yannay says:

Related issue: I put in a simple restitution claim with the Conference on Jewish Material Claims Against Germany, Inc in New York and still waiting for results after more than one year. This program was only opened recently for my age group.
At almost 76, I am the last survivor of my extended family in Hungary and Romania. For the obvious actuarial reason, every passing day more potential beneficiaries are dying out at an increasing pace. Tablet should investigate this outfit.

Solange Tajchman says:

There is no question that action is needed to remedy this shameful situation. The question is: how can the plight of Shoah survivors in Israel be addressed by Jews in the Diaspora in an effective manner?

Papa493 says:

Many — too many — in Israel are going hungry, not only Holocaust survivors.

Lamay Darnel says:

Israel is the home of over 15 millionaires,yet Jews in the diaspora contribute more,They will turn over their social security check to send to Israel to feed their fellow Jew and live on cat food ,tea and crackers. They think like my grandfather of blessed memory once told me when I cried because He gave me 2 pennies and my grandmother made me give one to her friends grandson,I should thank G-d because I was rich enough to give one penny away,as long as you can give a penny away and have one left you are Rich,because you can afford to give and G-d will bless you,The poor people are the ones that can not afford to give,Some can only give if they get a break on their taxes, ,Their is nothing wrong with getting an extra item at the food market and knocking on a door and saying hello HaShem told me you needed this.Organization pay there administration expense off the top first. So the more you give to them the more they take for themselves

CorinnaHasofferett says:
LJGlassman says:

ALL societies, not only Israel, should take care of ALL the elderly (not only Holocaust survivors). If not, as implied in the article, in a few years when “aid to survivors (is) unnecessary”, will it be OK for other elderly people to starve?

There are also elderly holocaust survivors living in poverty in Russia and they have even less help. It is horrible because they deserve a comfortable old age w/ food, heat, medicine ,clothing and more really. Thank you. I am going to dedicate myself to helping the survivors live out their days in contentment and this doesnt take much. They are not luxuary people. Everyone needs to help. What an answerto Hitler! I helped a jew today. What could be better?

You call me Anti- Semetic because I detest your murder of the Palestinian people for your fake religion of Zionism? THIS is the MOST HATEFUL ANTI-SEMETIC CRIME that exists in the WORLD TODAY! You are STEALING THE BILLIONS OF dollars given by the world each year to support these Holocaust Survivors! THESE are REAL JEWS! YOU ARE THE ANTI SEMTIC! ISRAEL’s SHAME ONLY CONTINUES TO FLOW INTO THE WORLD!

2000

Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Be a Mensch. Support Tablet.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Israel’s Starving Survivors

One in five Holocaust survivors in Israel goes hungry. We must fix this shame right away.

More on Tablet:

Klinghoffer at the Met

By Paul Berman — John Adams’s masterpiece is about an American Jew murdered by Palestinian terrorists, but the real opera is off stage