Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

Short and Sweet

A new book defends the height-challenged and teaches kids about the misuse of science

Print Email

When I was a kid, I was tall. Crazy tall. I was 5 feet 3 inches by the time I was 10. Everyone thought I’d ultimately reach 6 feet, like my Aunt Belleruth. Sure, Aunt Belleruth was gorgeous, but I wanted to look like everyone else. I envied Carolyn Schachter and Allison Page, the most petite girls in my class at Providence Hebrew Day School. They were adorable; I was a Sasquatch. I was fortunate that Pee-Wee’s Big Adventure hadn’t come out yet, or everyone would have called me Large Marge.

My first crush, Yoni Springer, was shorter than me. Of course, everyone was shorter than me. He was the smartest kid at camp and had the cutest smile. But he only liked me as a friend. I figured it was because I was dorky and awkward and uncute. I didn’t entirely blame my height, but my height was a huge part of why I felt dorky and awkward and uncute.

That’s why it was fascinating for me to read a children’s book called Short: Walking Tall When You’re Not Tall at All by John Schwartz, whose childhood problem was exactly the opposite of mine.

I grew up tall in Rhode Island, the biggest little state in the union. Schwartz grew up tiny in Texas, the biggest big state in the union. (We know each other in the online community The Well though we’ve never met in person.) Today, Schwartz is a reporter at The New York Times who often writes about science. He’s also 5 foot 3 inches tall.

Short is unusual for a book aimed at middle-grade readers—it’s a mix of memoir and reported nonfiction, a look at the science of shortness. Schwartz methodically demolishes popular claims that short people are less successful in life than tall ones. He talks to scientists whose research is frequently cited as “proof” that short people have worse lives (fewer friends, less money, less brainpower) than tall folks, and he lets them explain that their work has generally been misunderstood or misquoted. He teaches young readers how to examine studies critically: Who performed or paid for this research? (Hint: If it’s a company that wants to make money by selling human growth hormone to parents of short kids, is it a shock that the research seems to prove that shortness causes misery?)

Schwartz teaches readers the difference between correlation and causation, something a lot of adults don’t even understand. He gives kids some of the grossness they love, in a discussion of the Chinese propensity for stretching limbs surgically to meet height requirements for certain jobs. One of the scientists Schwartz talks to, David E. Sandberg, an associate professor of pediatrics at the University of Michigan, did research showing that being short does not actually cause kids lasting psychological trauma or hurt their popularity with their peers and yet found his work cited by the FDA as proof that short kids have huge problems.

All this science-y stuff is presented conversationally and leavened with lots of personal stories and humor. Schwartz makes the point that being funny and social was his key to popularity in school. “We all compensate in one way or another,” he told me in an interview. “Everyone has something that sets them apart—you might think you’re too fat, too scrawny, too smart, too big-nosed.” So, why must shortness be pathologized? Maybe what makes us different can actually make us special.

Schwartz wasn’t traumatized by being short. He told me that the only person who ever got to him was his mother. “There was this pipe at my elementary school that ran between one part of the building and another,” he said. “The boys would jump up and slap it, and I couldn’t. Not only was I small, I was not athletic in any way. I couldn’t touch the damn pipe, and it bothered me. I had a little heart-to-heart with my mom, telling her this. The next time she was at school, she called, ‘Johnny!’ I turned around and there she was, standing under the pipe, resting her hand on it and smiling. She’s 5 foot 10 inches. She was teasing me, but it was also her way of saying, ‘This is no big deal.’ All the kids who’d seen me try to touch that pipe laughed. It just killed me. I’d confided in her and she made fun of me. But after that, I stayed after school and made a run at that pipe again and again until I could hit it. And I came home and told her. And she smiled.”

My favorite thing about the book isn’t Schwartz’s short stories. It’s the education in media and science literacy, which every kid should have. “We’re dependent on science to make sense of the world,” Schwartz said. “The founders of our country understood that the free flow of information is vital to democracy, and if you don’t have the tools to approach science, you can’t be an effective citizen. You can’t make informed decisions about climate change. You won’t understand economics enough to know whether the stimulus package is working. I used shortness as a topic kids might care about as a way to learn how to think about science.”

I’d add that so many kids are suspicious of authority; we parents should try to channel that suspicion. For instance, there’s no more effective smoking-prevention strategy than to tell kids “cigarette companies want to take advantage of you.” (Telling them “smoking is dangerous” or “smoking is only for grown-ups” is tantamount to inviting Joe Camel to the kid’s birthday party.) So, why not teach kids how science has been manipulated to sell growth hormones and create attention-getting headlines in the attention-starved popular press?

One great audience for this book: boys who don’t like fiction. I always tell my friends whose sons don’t read to give them graphic novels, sports bios, or an encyclopedia of farts and vomit. Now I’ll also recommend a funny book about marketing and the misuse of science.

Finally, a confession: I’ve never been attracted to short guys. (Let me quickly say that I’ve never had a problem with fat and/or bald ones.) But I suspect that’s a holdover from my youthful self-image as Olive Oyl. We all have our mishegas. I’m not tall or skinny now—I hit 5 foot, 5 inches when I was 12 and then simply stopped growing, at least vertically. Now I’m only a bit taller than the average American woman. (She’s 5 foot 4 inches. The average American man is 5 foot 10 inches.) But the heart wants what it wants, to quote someone one shouldn’t ever quote on the subject of human attraction. When I was dating, I was still carrying my own baggage. But things change. I was never attracted to back hair, techno, or the art of Victor Vasarely, but I love Jonathan, my husband, and now all those things are fine by me. So, I’d say to short boys (the book, alas, doesn’t really go into the problems specific to short girls): You’ll find someone who will love you. Look at John Schwartz: happily married to his high-school sweetheart, with three gorgeous kids. All of whom are taller than he is. But who’s measuring?

Print Email

Daily rate: $2
Monthly rate: $18
Yearly rate: $180

Tablet is committed to bringing you the best, smartest, most enlightening and entertaining reporting and writing on Jewish life, all free of charge. We take pride in our community of readers, and are thrilled that you choose to engage with us in a way that is both thoughtful and thought-provoking. But the Internet, for all of its wonders, poses challenges to civilized and constructive discussion, allowing vocal—and, often, anonymous—minorities to drag it down with invective (and worse). Starting today, then, we are asking people who'd like to post comments on the site to pay a nominal fee—less a paywall than a gesture of your own commitment to the cause of great conversation. All proceeds go to helping us bring you the ambitious journalism that brought you here in the first place.

Readers can still interact with us free of charge via Facebook, Twitter, and our other social media channels, or write to us at Each week, we’ll select the best letters and publish them in a new letters to the editor feature on the Scroll.

We hope this new largely symbolic measure will help us create a more pleasant and cultivated environment for all of our readers, and, as always, we thank you deeply for your support.

Great review and wonderful idea for a book. Having topped out at my adult height (4’11”) in seventh grade, I long ago came to terms with the limitations of my lesser verticality — constant hemming, step ladders in every room, getting lost in big places. Marrying a tall man (6’2″) took care of limitations two (he does the reaching) and three (I can see him anywhere). Whenever I can, I buy capris that work as regular slacks. But the best thing has been my yoga practice. Five years of asanas and I now measure 5′ even. Every time I go to the doctor. At a time when science would tell you I should be shrinking, I’ve gained an inch of height. If this keeps up, my (now 6’1″) hubby and I may meet somewhere around 5’7″.

Jeff Carpenter says:

Read “A Prayer for Owen Meany”—

Jessica says:

This is a wonderful book, just as Marjorie describes it — informative, funny, challenging. I’ve saved it for my 8 year old, short, science-curious son and look forward to his enjoyment of it and the world of inquiry it opens up.

Rahel says:

This sounds like a great book. I’ll be passing your article along to my colleagues in the science department — sounds like a wonderful resource for them.

observer says:

It is shameful of Ms. Ingall to tout: “Maybe what makes us different can actually make us special,” while bashing parents of children who are neuroanatomically and cognitively different than 95% or more of the population. Her judgy, judgy, judgy shtick is bigoted and tiresome; moreover, Ms. Ingall demonstrates her overt hypocrisy by elsewhere writing about inclusion and exhorting others to be menschy when she herself exhibits neither quality. Her vitriolic, misinformed blogging brings shame upon your publication. Tablet Magazine would do well to lose her as a contributor. Marjorie Ingall is petty, meanspirited, and ignorant.

A certain form of “Short man syndrome” — short stature combined with early maturation — may have some not insignificant impact on success. At least in the following men, whatever “height impairment” they may have experienced did not hold them back.

Famously “short-statured” Napoleon Bonaparte was a relative giant at 5’6″.
At 5′ 4″ are/were Mel Brooks, Pablo Picasso, Sammy Davis Jr., Harry Houdini, Truman Capote
5’3″: Paul Simon, Mickey Rooney, Nikita Krushchev, Mahatma Gandhi,
5’2″: Buckminster Fuller
5’1″: English poet Keats
4’10.5″: Robert Reich, Sec of Labor under Pres Clinton

Why is it that when a short man is successful it is a syndrome? Aren’t you supposed to strive to be successful at any height? If a woman of 5’3″ is successful, does she have a syndrome? At what height does this supposed syndrome stop 5’8″; 5’9″? It seems tay no matter what a short man does or doeswn’t do, a negative label is always attached. What if those same short men weren’t as succeasful, I guess they would be losers right? Damned if you do and damned if you don’t. Unreal!!

I haven’t read Mr. Schwartz’s book but my impression of it is that it’s not a serious work that short people need to read. If it’s directed at middle-schoolers that’s fine. I think the short-statured should be past the point where we have to read about height and shortness being presented in a jocular fashion. It’s always a joke, always viewed as funny. “Schwartz makes the point that being funny and social was his key to popularity in school”. – This is not about popularity, it’s about prejudice. People are prejudiced toward the short, pure and simple. I’m sure Mr. Schwartz would never write about Anti-Antisemitism in a jocular vein, or racism or prejudice based on any other characteristic. If this is his way to get his foot in the door and sell his book, I’m not going to buy it. The stories I get from people writing to me at my website and the personal experiences that short people have are incredible – if these demeaning experiences occurred based on characteristics like race, religion, sex, ethnicity, age, etc. many would be viewed as hate crimes. I can understand Mr. Schwartz targeting kids and trying to assist short kids, but heightism is not a joke. It’s a prejudice; a real prejudice. I treat it as such on my website.

I suggest reading the book before criticizing it. (Generally a good idea in any case.) It is a serious and scholarly look at shortness research, presenting in a very compelling way — in an informal, friendly, warm and funny voice. The jokey, prejudice-encouraging book Mr Mangano describes is not the book I read.

l aitrice prende spunto dal libro del lore , qualcuno sa di che si tratta ???

You could certainly see your expertise in the work you write. The world hopes for more passionate writers like you who are not afraid to say how they believe. Always go after your heart.

Hey there wanted to provide you with a fast manages. The written text inside your post appear to be running off the display within Internet explorer. I am not sure if this can be a format problem or something like that to do with internet browser match ups but I thought Id publish to show you. The design look great although! We do hope you obtain the problem resolved soon. Thank you

Thank you for another wonderful post. Where else could anybody get that kind of information in such an ideal way of writing? I have a presentation next week, and I am on the look for such information.

I’ve said that least 4382267 times. The problem this like that is they are just too compilcated for the average bird, if you know what I mean

Interested in a sensible way to shed weight fast, deal with selected fat, and thus get rid of excess 10 pounds in less than a few days you should read this blog site.


Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Short and Sweet

A new book defends the height-challenged and teaches kids about the misuse of science

More on Tablet:

Obama: Denying Israel’s Right to Exist as a Jewish Homeland is Anti-Semitic

By Yair Rosenberg — The president draws a line in the sand in his latest interview