Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

Facing the Naked Truth About My Father’s Declining Health, and What It Means for Me

When I was young, my father cared for me. Now he’s old and needs my help, but can I really provide it?

Print Email
Related Content

My Father and the Talmud

I idolized my dad and resented him. As I’ve untangled our relationship, I adopted his passion: Talmud study

It starts as just another Sunday visit with Dad. He has been having some trouble breathing, and he is shaky on his feet. When it’s time for me to leave, he asks me to stay a little longer. “I need to take a shower,” he says with apology. “I am afraid to do it alone.” I nod. He needs me there to spot him, to make sure he doesn’t slip. He is suffering from a blockage in his lung, and his doctor has advised him not to bathe alone.

Everything is in order. My father, a military man and quintessential planner, has strategically placed towels here, clean clothes there, chairs where he can rest between his bed and the shower. But still, as he limps across the room, stopping every few steps to catch his breath, he says: “Don’t leave. I need you.”

I am angry. I don’t want to be doing this. But my mind wrestles with itself: This is the man who formed me, diapered me, rocked me in the cradle. He taught me how to tie my shoes, zip up my coat, balance a checkbook, study a page of Talmud.

Of course I stay—my father needs me. But that does not stop irrational thoughts from erupting inside, as though I’m still 15 years old and he is 45: Since when am I supposed to take care of him? Why doesn’t he just take care of himself? He’s the father, for God’s sake. But for some of us, as adults we must now return the lifetime of care to our parents, even if inside we never feel grown up enough to take care of anyone. As Father’s Day reminds us—not that we needed the reminder—a father is a father is a father. He cared for you; now you care for him.


As a child, I was by his side, marching in lockstep as he went to shul to do his rabbinical duties. I went with him when he officiated at funerals and unveilings. He would offer a few words and the mourners would burst into tears just like that; it was a kind of dark magic, to make people cry—little did I know then, it was a kindness. I loved learning about all his experiences, like when he was chaplain at the Atlanta Federal Penitentiary and ministered to the famous gangster Mickey Cohen, but it was a little overwhelming, too. At every step, he shared with me his thoughts, even if I might have been too young to grasp it all. I remember when I was 6 years old in 1970, he gave me his opinions on the war in Vietnam, the counterculture, the generation gap. I stood there stalwart, part loving shadow, part valet, part footman in training, taking it all in.

I knew his enemies, too. When I was 12, he engaged in a fight for his professional life. Some members of a local yeshiva where he had been principal had conspired to throw him out. War was declared, pitting parents and board members against each other. Parts of the neighborhood chose sides, and some of our family’s friends became personae non grata. The fight was only resolved when my father got into his gold Chevrolet Biscayne (with air-conditioning and power-steering!) and drove to the Lower East Side to see the sage of the day, Rabbi Moshe Feinstein, at Mesivta Tifereth Jerusalem. My father told him his woes, and the sage took out a piece of his letterhead and wrote simply in the holy tongue in his own pen: “It is forbidden to remove this man from his position.” My father returned from this trip holding this piece of paper and crying as I had never before or since seen him cry. At the time, I didn’t understand why he was crying, although I think I understand now: He was being bullied in the playground, and the diminutive sage from the Lower East Side, the giant of our generation, had stood up for him and told those bullies to scat.

Not all of his battles were emotional. His body still bears the physical scars of a terrible accident 33 years ago. He was run over by a drunk driver while putting etrogim into the trunk of his car. It put him in the hospital for seven months; he had 19 operations and spent three years in a wheelchair. He was, for quite a while, an invalid, and we all took care of him. We brought him his food, his clothes. We drove him everywhere. He rewarded us by recovering vigorously with almost superhuman determination.

My father’s battles were mine, his views and his versions of events were all mine, and they embedded themselves deeply into my blood. What was the price of carrying my father’s thoughts? Our relationship was both a link and a barrier to the world, a protective and exclusive bromance. Play ball? Take a run? Date a girl? Wear a loud shirt? I did all these things, of course, but I had a second layer of skin to consider, another set of opinions to keep in mind.

And now, after all those years, with all that history hanging over us, I had to watch my father bare himself to me—literally—because the contract between us had turned decisively. In the end, he needed me.


I gather his clothes, his bottle of water, a washcloth. I put his worn clothes in the hamper, get clean socks and a pair of freshly pressed pajamas from the drawer. Finally, with me shadowing him, he made it to the bathroom and turned on the water.

“Are you all right?” I called into the bathroom.

“Come to the door, listen,” he tells me. “I have something to tell you.”

I come to the doorway. I can feel the spirit of Mother, dead since last year, hovering over the bathroom. We both feel her.

“You know, what kept me and Ma together all those years?” he asks. “It was her beauty. It was physical. Physical, I tell you. … She was an absolutely astoundingly beautiful woman, and her physicality imprinted itself on me from the moment I met her.”

I nod my head. The carnal candor is bracing, even refreshing, and yet not entirely unexpected. After all, the bath setting is famous for a kind of frank, male banter. But hearing this is also if not exactly a burden, then certainly a perverse privilege. Our bonds have been formed so tightly that at times there seems scarcely any space between us, as though we are brothers peering out of the foxhole of life: He sleeps and I stand guard, I sleep and he stands guard. We can rely on each other—perhaps too well and too much.

“How are your finances?” he shouts from the shower.

“They’re fine,” I tell him.

“I hate to see you still carrying all that debt.”

“I have paid much of it down,” I tell him.

“I want to give you some money,” he says. “Why suffer? Why not have?”

I am already 50, but he wants to be the father to me, still. It makes me queasy. I don’t want his money, but am I doing him a favor by taking it? The giving and taking between us has always been blurred in unending thick fog.

“I know you need it,” he says. “You need something. Take it. You can always use.”

“Do you really want to give it to me?” I straighten the room for him.

“If it is useful to you, I want you to have it.”

“But do you want to give it to me?”

“I am happy for you to have it.”

This is when the conversation between intimates reaches irrational levels, looping around like an endless newsreel with no “off” switch. We see each other, and yet we don’t see each other at all.

I play the solemn bath attendant. I am quiet, waiting, sympathetic. It is no wonder that I developed a career as a psychoanalyst, to accept the confidences of men and women, to cultivate the crops of a temporarily barren mind with both words and silence. Some men don’t want to be cured of their madness. They wear it like a snug-fitting shoe.

The water in the bath drains. Like the good sons of Noah I hold out the towel for him from behind without looking.

I help him get his freshly showered, lotioned body into his pajamas.

“Will you take the money?” he asks again.

“Not now,” I tell him. “Get better first. Then we’ll talk about it.” Despite his breathing, I am confident he will get better.

I help him into bed. He rests easy now, ready for sleep. I feel pride in a good job: I helped him. Just before I leave, he tells me, “You know? The problem with my lungs? It could be Ma. I haven’t shed enough tears over her, and the water is going into my lungs.”

This is a startling and touching revelation. It has the ring of truth. The grief over the woman is lodged between us. “I think so much of my need for you and your brother is a way of avoiding those tears,” he says. Once again, I am the link and the barrier.

I hug him goodnight and leave the house. The next morning we talk on the phone. “I feel better,” he says. Slowly, over the ensuing weeks, he starts to recover.

Perhaps I have given him something he needs. Once I stop resisting taking care of him and actually apply myself heart and soul to the task at hand—not just then, but in the ensuing weeks and months, together with my siblings—I find I am no longer angry at all. I became young again in a different way: I have the energy of life and take a young man’s simple pleasure in doing the right thing. I don’t need anyone to tell me what is right. I have become a father to myself and healed my old man.


Like this article? Sign up for our Daily Digest to get Tablet Magazine’s new content in your inbox each morning.

Print Email

Daily rate: $2
Monthly rate: $18
Yearly rate: $180

Tablet is committed to bringing you the best, smartest, most enlightening and entertaining reporting and writing on Jewish life, all free of charge. We take pride in our community of readers, and are thrilled that you choose to engage with us in a way that is both thoughtful and thought-provoking. But the Internet, for all of its wonders, poses challenges to civilized and constructive discussion, allowing vocal—and, often, anonymous—minorities to drag it down with invective (and worse). Starting today, then, we are asking people who'd like to post comments on the site to pay a nominal fee—less a paywall than a gesture of your own commitment to the cause of great conversation. All proceeds go to helping us bring you the ambitious journalism that brought you here in the first place.

Readers can still interact with us free of charge via Facebook, Twitter, and our other social media channels, or write to us at Each week, we’ll select the best letters and publish them in a new letters to the editor feature on the Scroll.

We hope this new largely symbolic measure will help us create a more pleasant and cultivated environment for all of our readers, and, as always, we thank you deeply for your support.

The Wifely Person says:

Welcome to the new reality.

The Torah tells us to “honor” our parents. Sometimes, doing that is more challenging than just loving them. Nine years ago, when it became clear my father-in-law, the least social human on the planet, could no longer be on his own, we asked him to come live with us. Since then, my husband (an only child) has passed away, but my father-in-law remains with me. At 92, he is in pretty good shape but for his eyesight, and we have settled into an amicable routine. My own parents, 92 and 90, are in Florida (of course) and would love to get the same level of attention that my FIL gets…but they understand.

None of them expected to live this long. Nor did my aunts and one remaining uncle. Or their friends. Or my friends who are now attempting to care for people who have led fiercely independent lives….while facing their own incipient retirement. Does one give up one’s “plans” in order to care for the senior generation?

With luck, the good days outnumber the bad one, and the ability to laugh has not been completely lost. And you tell yourself over and over you’re doing the right thing and anything else would impede your ability to live with yourself.

You are not alone in facing this. I hope you having siblings to help. And a supportive family of your own. That makes a difference.

alustiger says:

Rabbi Soloveitchik once gave a shiur suggesting that true Kibud Av Ve’aim takes place with the role reversal that you have described: when it is the parent that becomes dependent on the child. Your description is very moving.

disqus_wefb6Xz2V7 says:

For those of you who have asked, whatever had been ailing my father, has now disappeared and he is in fine form — both teaching at the Azrieli Graduate School at Yeshiva University and is back at his school-consulting practice full-time.

Eric M Weis says:

The Feuerman family has been blessed. My father not only refused my help, but actually placed legal obstacles in the path of his only wife and only child. She never divorced him, and I never left him. But, for reasons that only he could fathom, we were prevented from caring from him, and could only watch from the sidelines as non-family members interfered in the most basic of human relations. The pain, over a six year period of his decline, was unbearable. My father passed away in January. We loved him for all the years before, and I say Kaddish for him, every day.

The Bochur says:

Has your father agreed and does he know that his intimate and private
conversations with you will be published online to illustrate your fine
feelings? And has he given consent to this?

    disqus_wefb6Xz2V7 says:

    yes, I showed it to him and he said, “let the world learn what they can from who we are”

    disqus_wefb6Xz2V7 says:

    in fact, he said, “you must publish this.”

I think you’ve answered your own question about whether or not you can take care of him.

In my experience, we rise to the occasion because we must. No parent ever faced the birth of their first child with certainty that they could care for it any more than we can be certain we can take care of our parents in their hour of need. We do it not just because we must, but because indeed we can. We find the way when the time comes, as it will for most of us.

For myself, I found that the months during which I cared for my father before he died became some of the most rewarding time I’d ever spent with him; a time of closeness, and for us, great healing. Since he passed away, I’ve felt a much deeper sense of peace than I imagined possible as a result. I still mourn him every day, but I will always carry the knowledge that I know I helped him a lot, including making sure he was able to remain independent as long as possible, and that his passing was as peaceful as it was humanly possible to make it. Knowing that he trusted me to help him and to do right by him when he was at his most vulnerable was one of the most precious gifts he could have ever given me.

Stopping resisting is the first step – including resisting that the necessity to help them has in fact arisen.

When I really got that my father was sick and not just being a pain in the butt, like you, all anger and frustration towards him fled and was replaced with infinitely more patience than I ever could have imagined. The child does indeed become the father to the man, in more ways than one. I can totally relate to the “simple pleasure of doing the right thing.”

Your father sounds like a remarkable man, and I’m glad he’s recovered. I wish you many more years together.

    disqus_wefb6Xz2V7 says:

    Wendy, what a beautiful, thoughtful and generous response. You summed it up so well in your sharing.

    disqus_wefb6Xz2V7 says:

    Yes, and you’re right about my father. I appreciate your good wishes.

EvelynKrieger says:

Your father is a poet. When he is gone you will not regret the time you spent and the care you gave him. He will heal you.


Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Facing the Naked Truth About My Father’s Declining Health, and What It Means for Me

When I was young, my father cared for me. Now he’s old and needs my help, but can I really provide it?