Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another


Eye on Unity and U.S., Bibi Calls for Early Vote

Move also extends unconstitutional Tal Law, about Haredi military service

Print Email
Prime Minister Netanyahu addressing the Likud Party yesterday.(Jack Guez/AFP/GettyImages)

As suspected, Prime Minister Netanyahu called for elections on September 4 (when laws require that they not be held until October of next year at the latest).

The foremost technical reason is actually something that does not get nearly as much press stateside as issues like Iran, the peace process, or even the high cost of housing in Tel Aviv: the Tal Law. This was the statute, passed about a decade ago, that created a mechanism for Haredi national service, either in the IDF or through civil means The problem is that, first, earlier this year, the High Court ruled it unconstitutional; and, second, various Israel parties, most notably Yisrael Beiteinu, want a new service law that places more severe requirements on the Haredi community.

However, as a result of the Knesset’s likely dissolving itself today in preparation for the elections, the unconstitutional law will actually be extended until after the elections—after which, a new coalition might shape whatever replaces it. Though YB plans to try to bring their bill before a ministerial committee today (and other parties have pledged their own service bills) and seek a one-week postponement of dissolution, they are expected to fail. Politics!

In a speech to the Likud Party yesterday, Netanyahu—in his first public appearance since the death of his father Benzion, a week before—said that the snap elections were intended to contribute to stability by restricting campaigning to merely four months. But as we know, among his greater motivations is to put himself in a strong position should President Obama be re-elected in November and should Netanyahu decide Israel will attack Iran’s nuclear facilities. While some (including myself) assumed that the closeness of the Israeli and U.S. election days—September 4 (probably) and November 6—would preclude a new Bibi-led government’s attack until November, one Israeli report stated that the September elections are intended, precisely, to allow Netanyahu to attack in that window. Jonathan Tobin makes the valuable point that part of the usefulness here, as always, is the mere threat, which insures the West won’t go soft on negotiations and sanctions. (As Dennis Ross asserted this weekend, the Israeli talk is intended more to goad the world than announce its own intentions.)

It’s a window that’s likely to last fewer than two months. After elections, Netanyahu will still need to form a coalition, which will require choosing and bargaining with, as Shmuel Rosner notes, basically everyone: if polls hold, Bibi will be in position to form another right-wing coalition; a more centrist, national unity-style coalition; or any combination thereof.

What’s more clear is that after September 4, Israel will have the same head of government.

Netanyahu Calls for Early Elections in Israel [NYT]
Yisrael Beiteinu Seeks to Postpone Knesset Dissolution [Ynet]
Iran, Obama, and Bibi’s October Surprise [Commentary Contentions
Netanyahu’s Game of Coalition-Building [Jewish Journal Rosner’s Domain]
Earlier: How Israeli Elections Affect an Attack on Iran

Print Email
JehudahBenIsrael says:

The Israeli public, by and large, stands firm behind this move by the Likud and Qadimah, especially in light of the four issues that have been highlighted as essential to resolve, and can be resolved by a coalition in which the main Zionist parties are part, including Likud, Qadimah, Israel Beitenu, ‘Atzmaut, HaBait HaJehudi: 

1. The change of the governing system 
2. The ensuring that all, including Haredim and Arabs, serve either in uniform or civil national service
3. Advancing the peace process with the Palestine Liberation organization (PLO) 
4. Passing next year bi-annual budget 

In addition to these four items it should be kept in mind that should Israel decide to attack Iran, the citizens of Israel would like to see this happens under a national unity coalition. 

Let us hope the three other Zionist parties, i.e. Labor, Meretz and the National Union will stand by this government in its efforts to overcome these four issues to Israel’s national and security interests.


Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Eye on Unity and U.S., Bibi Calls for Early Vote

Move also extends unconstitutional Tal Law, about Haredi military service

More on Tablet:

A Tale of Three Twitter Feeds: Hamas Tweets in Arabic, English, and Hebrew

By Aaron Magid — Analysis of the social-media messaging of Hamas’ military wing reveals distinct voices for the West, the Arab Middle East, and Israel