Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another


Where Is Jerusalem?

A question everybody and nobody wants to answer

Print Email

NEW YORK — In the fall, the U.S. Supreme Court will hear a case concerning a 2002 law that established Israel as the country of birth of people born in Jerusalem for passport purposes. The legal questions involved have little to do with the status of Jerusalem. Rather, the Court will consider whether Congress’ law conflicts with the executive branch’s constitutional authority to make foreign policy, as well as whether it is the judicial branch’s place to adjudicate this dispute, which may never have existed had President George W. Bush not signed the law and then added a signing statement declaring he would ignore it.

Israel considers Jerusalem its undivided capital, having annexed those parts of it east of the Green Line following the Six Day War. But no countries have their embassies there due to the sensitive nature of the topic; the CIA World Factbook states that Israel’s capital is Jerusalem, while noting that the U.S. embassy is in Tel Aviv. “The United States’ consistent policy has been to recognize no state as having sovereignty over Jerusalem, leaving the issue to be decided by negotiation between the parties to the Arab-Israeli dispute,” the administration’s brief, which argued that the Court should not hear the case, said. Congress’ involvement in the issue “would critically compromise the United States’ ability to help further the Middle East peace process,” it added. So no help there. Where to turn?

In Miracle on 34th Street (spoiler alert!), Kris Kringle’s attorney proves his case by demonstrating that a branch of the federal government ( the U.S. Postal Service) forwarded his client letters addressed to Santa Claus, implicitly endorsing his client’s claim that, in fact, he is the real thing. Of course, it’s the federal government that is divided here, so I had to contact a yet higher authority to resolve the question of where Jerusalem is. I chose the Associated Press. But they have a clever dodge in place, too! You see, Jerusalem is one of 49 non-U.S. cities (46 if you don’t count Monaco, San Marino, and Vatican City as cities) that, according to the latest AP Stylebook, does not require a clarifying country in its bylines. If you are writing from Tel Aviv, your piece is to be datelined, “TEL AVIV, Israel.” From Jerusalem? Just, “JERUSALEM.” In many of the cases, the clarifying country is pretty clearly left out because it is unnecessary: Most readers don’t need to be told which countries “BEIJING,” “ROME,” or indeed “KUWAIT CITY” are in. But I wonder if the inclusion of Jerusalem, coupled with the exclusion of Tel Aviv, isn’t a shrewd posture of neutrality. The AP is kicking the question of Jerusalem down the road. You know, just like everybody else.

Question of Birth Becomes One of President’s Power [NYT]
Related: The Acrobat [Tablet Magazine]

Print Email
Hershel (Heshy) Ginsburg says:

Actually, until not too long ago, there WERE several embassies in Jerusalem; if my memory serves me well (and it may not), there were even more until Israel formally annexed the post-67 neighborhoods. The last hold outs were some Central American countries (I believe Panama & Cost Rica & maybe others) who maintained embassies in Jerusalem in exchange for Israel maintaining full-time embassies & ambassadors in their declared capitals.

I don’t recall exactly when & why the last of the CentAms left, but I think it was in the late 90s or early 2000s in response primarily to increasing Arab pressure (so much for the Oslo Accords) and possibly in response to an Israeli budgetary decision to cut back on the embassies in their capitals (although that may have come afterward).


Why shouldn’t it be the capital of Israel? It wasw never the capital of any other country. While Jordan occupied it (48-67) it certainly wasn’t their capital. Before that it was part of British Mandate Palestine – not a capital then, either. Under the Ottoman Turks (500 years) it was nothing.
So, if it hasn’t been the capital of any other country and Israel wants to make it hers, I say, Kol HaKavod!


Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Where Is Jerusalem?

A question everybody and nobody wants to answer

More on Tablet:

Many Holocaust Survivors Live in Poverty Today

By Stephanie Butnick — On Holocaust Remembrance Day, thinking of—and helping—survivors in need