Ed Koch ‘Not Liberal Enough for the West Side’
An excerpt from Stars of David: Prominent Jews Talk About Being Jewish
In 2005, Abigail Pogrebin published Stars of David: Prominent Jews Talk About Being Jewish. The following is an excerpt from the chapter about Ed Koch, the former mayor who was buried today in New York City.
Edward Irving Koch grew up in Newark, New Jersey, and attended the Hebrew Free School. âThe teaching was terrible,â he says. His father, Louis, was a furrier, and his mother, Joyce Silpe, was a âterrible cook.â She burned everything,â he says with a laugh. âAnd my father loved everything to be burned. I like rare food. I like it bloody.â
He says his mother was determined to assimilate. âShe hired a tutor to teach her to lose her Yiddish Central European accent.â
In his last year of college, he was drafted into the army, where he âhad a fight because I was a Jew.â It all started because his platoon, according to Koch, was composed of twenty-five percent Jewish New Yorkers. âIt was an unusual number,â he says, âand many of them simply couldnât do the obstacle course. I must say, I found it hard, but I practiced. I wanted to look good. What the Jewish kids did excel in was asking questions. So when they had seminars, the Jewish kids would put up their hands and ask questions. And one day, this one guy said, âWhich is the next Yid thatâs going to ask a question?â I knew I couldnât take on a fight because I wasnât strong enough yetâ this happened in the first few weeks of basic training. So I said, âIâm going to build myself up and ultimately Iâm going to challenge him.ââ
Koch trained hard over the next sixteen weeks. âIt didnât help,â Koch admits with a smile, âhe still beat me up. But I was proud of the mere fact that I challenged him. I went over to him and grabbed him by the throat and I said, âWeâre going to have it out.â And he said, âWhy? What did I do?â And I couldnât say to him, âItâs because of what you said.â He looked baffled, but all I could say to him was, âYou know. You know.ââ
I wonder if, once Koch got to be the blustery, bigheaded, likable mayor of New York, he became more Jewish on the job than he had been. He nods. âSure. It made me speak out more. I am very proud of the fact that, as a result of being identified as proud of my faith, I got higher percentages of Catholic votes than I got from the Jews.â Like most dyed-in-the-wool candidates, Koch rattles off numbers: âEighty-one percent of the Italians and the Irish supported me in my elections, whereas with the Jews, it was only seventy-three percent, and the reason is very simple: Iâm not liberal enough for the West Side Jew. And Iâm proud of that! I am a moderate! Jews have a very large group that is too radical for me in a host of areas. But the Catholics love me. Iâm proud of the fact that John Cardinal OâConnor asked me to do a book with him. It was called His Eminence and Hizzoner.â
Koch makes sure to attend synagogue on the High Holy Days every year, though he never had a seder at Gracie Mansion. âBut I put up a mezuzah on the door there,â he points out. âAbe Beame had a mezuzah.â (He refers to a famous predecessor.) âBut I had a better mezuzah. And when my father died, we sat shivah at Gracie Mansion. That was nice.â
When I ask him if he feels more Jewish or more American, he winces. âItâs not a question that should be asked. Look, I am an American. I happen to be a white male, a senior citizen, and Iâm Jewish. If I had to pick the two things Iâm proud of, itâs being an American and being a Jew. But my overall allegiance is American.â
Koch pulls out an anecdote to illustrate: âWhen I was a congressman, early on, I noted that they had prayer breakfasts in Washington every two weeks, where a group of legislators would meet for breakfast and discuss religious matters. One day, a congressman from Mississippi, Sonny Montgomery, meets me on the House floor and says, âEd, next week we want to discuss Judaism. You are a Jew?â âYes, I am a Jew.â âWould you come and lecture on Judaism?â I said, âSure.â At the time, I thought, âIâm not a scholar, how much do I know? Iâll go to the library and figure out what will amuse them.â I took out a couple books, read them, and went to the breakfast. And I told them about Jewish exotica, which they enjoyed, and then they asked questions. At the end, I said, âWhatâs interesting to me is you are all avoiding a question which I know is on your minds by looking in your eyes. And the question that youâre not asking me is, âDo Jews have dual loyalty?â Isnât that what youâre wondering?â They all nodded. âSo I want to make you one pledge,â and I raised my right hand. âI swear to you, that if Israel ever invades the United States, I shall stand with the United States.â And they roared.â
But Koch does have a deep fealty to Israel that clearly makes him hyper-aware of when itâs the target of condemnation. âItâs clear to me that anti-Semitism has re-arisen to an extent even greater than before World War II, without the killings in concentration camps,â he says. âI donât want to overstate it, but I mean, itâs amazingâ the hate and the venom. Itâs directed at Israel because it wouldnât be acceptable in polite circles to direct it at Jews, but itâs intended to be directed at all Jews.â
I ask how he would explain this Jewish hatred. âFirst: anti-Semitism is based, in large part, on actions of the church; and weâre very lucky there have been popes who have changed that to an enormous degree. But take Cardinal Glemp in Poland. I met him; he is a vile anti-Semite. And heâs the primateâthe number one cardinal. So in Europe in particular, you have still the residue of that.
âSecond is: Weâre supposed to be dead! âWhy are you still standing?!â Thereâs a certain resentment: âHow could it be? Weâve kicked the shit out of them; why are they still standing?ââ
Excerpted from Stars of David: Prominent Jews Talk About Being Jewish by Abigail Pogrebin. Copyright 2005 by Abigail Pogrebin. Used by permission of Broadway Books, a division of Random House, Inc.
Daily rate: $2
Monthly rate: $18
Yearly rate: $180
WAIT, WHY DO I HAVE TO PAY TO COMMENT?
Tablet is committed to bringing you the best, smartest, most enlightening and entertaining reporting and writing on Jewish life, all free of charge. We take pride in our community of readers, and are thrilled that you choose to engage with us in a way that is both thoughtful and thought-provoking. But the Internet, for all of its wonders, poses challenges to civilized and constructive discussion, allowing vocalâand, often, anonymousâminorities to drag it down with invective (and worse). Starting today, then, we are asking people who'd like to post comments on the site to pay a nominal feeâless a paywall than a gesture of your own commitment to the cause of great conversation. All proceeds go to helping us bring you the ambitious journalism that brought you here in the first place.
I NEED TO BE HEARD! BUT I DONT WANT TO PAY.
Readers can still interact with us free of charge via Facebook, Twitter, and our other social media channels, or write to us at firstname.lastname@example.org. Each week, weâll select the best letters and publish them in a new letters to the editor feature on the Scroll.
We hope this new largely symbolic measure will help us create a more pleasant and cultivated environment for all of our readers, and, as always, we thank you deeply for your support.