Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another


Times Mistakes Gaza Terrorists For Journalists

David Carr makes a huge reporting mistake

Print Email

There are few journalists who write as capably and accessibly about media and journalism trends as the Times‘ David Carr. A lot of people seem to carry this opinion, so I imagine there was some surprise when the above-pictured tweet went out from Carr’s Twitter account to his 400,000 or so followers.

Carr had decided to go fishing for a story about journalists who had been targeted in Gaza during Operation Pillar of Defense. As someone who followed the war closely, I assumed that his unnerving search would yield little results; after all, for a mind as insightful and sharply tuned to nuance as Carr’s, I wouldn’t have expected him to bite on a story that wasn’t true. But he did.

In his ominously-titled column “Using War as Cover to Target Journalists” today, Carr starts by describing a scene at a Waldorf Astoria gala for the Committee to Protect Journalists, before citing one of the organization’s grim statistics:

The C.P.J. reports that government officials and their allies are now suspected of being responsible for more than a third of the murders of journalists, a higher proportion than killings attributed to terrorist groups or criminal enterprises.

For his first example, Carr doesn’t dig into Syria, where approximately 20 journalists were killed from November of last year until this September. He doesn’t start with Russia or Mexico either. He starts, of course, in Gaza.

On the same day as the Waldorf event, three employees of news organizations were killed in Gaza by Israeli missiles. Rather than suggesting it was a mistake, or denying responsibility, an Israeli Defense Forces spokeswoman, Lt. Col. Avital Leibovich, told The Associated Press, “The targets are people who have relevance to terror activity.”

So it has come to this: killing members of the news media can be justified by a phrase as amorphous as “relevance to terror activity.”

The outrage would be righteous if the men were simply journalists. But when Leibovich told the AP that the men were linked to terrorist activity, she wasn’t making some callous statement about targeting journalists who disagree with the state.

As the IDF Blog reported (or really anyone with internet access could have reported), one of the men killed was a senior Hamas member:

Muhammed Shamalah, commander of Hamas forces in the southern Strip and head of the Hamas militant training programs, was targeted by an Israeli air strike while driving a car clearly labelled “TV”, indicating it to be a press vehicle, abusing the protection afforded to journalists.

To that the Elder of Ziyon added about Mohamed Abu Aisha, a man whom Carr describes as the “director of the private Al-Quds Educational Radio” in the story:

In the case of Mohamed Abu Aisha, he clearly was a uniform-wearing member of Islamic Jihad. Islamic Jihad doesn’t describe him as a journalist, but as an instructor for the Mujahideen of Al-Quds Brigades in Deir al-Balah Battalion Brigade.

The post includes a picture of Aisha in his military garb. Carr goes on for paragraphs more, citing excoriations by Human Rights Watch and Reporters Without Borders as proof of Israeli perniciousness. He then rightly and finally delves into the rest of the world, saving a remark about Syria–“the deadliest country for journalists this year”–to kick off one of the last paragraphs on the article’s second page.

Of course, Carr’s not wrong to want to defend journalists. But what about the truth?

At Leasts 19 Journalist Killed in Syria Since November [Reuters]
Senior Terrorist in Gaza Disguises Himself as Journalist [IDF]
Or Journalists as Cover for Waging War [Elders]

Print Email

Daily rate: $2
Monthly rate: $18
Yearly rate: $180

Tablet is committed to bringing you the best, smartest, most enlightening and entertaining reporting and writing on Jewish life, all free of charge. We take pride in our community of readers, and are thrilled that you choose to engage with us in a way that is both thoughtful and thought-provoking. But the Internet, for all of its wonders, poses challenges to civilized and constructive discussion, allowing vocal—and, often, anonymous—minorities to drag it down with invective (and worse). Starting today, then, we are asking people who'd like to post comments on the site to pay a nominal fee—less a paywall than a gesture of your own commitment to the cause of great conversation. All proceeds go to helping us bring you the ambitious journalism that brought you here in the first place.

Readers can still interact with us free of charge via Facebook, Twitter, and our other social media channels, or write to us at Each week, we’ll select the best letters and publish them in a new letters to the editor feature on the Scroll.

We hope this new largely symbolic measure will help us create a more pleasant and cultivated environment for all of our readers, and, as always, we thank you deeply for your support.

Cool_Romeo says:

I’ve said it before, I’ll say it again. Tablet has really taken a turn for the better over the past several months.

    Leslie78 says:

    Agreed. Someone appears to have figured out that the liberal viewpoint isn’t the only one out there, and in many instances isn’t the honest one either.

I will be hugely impressed with David Carr if he doesn’t resort the standard New York Times feint when it comes to being questioned, throwing up a smokescreen of condescension and wounded vanity. Looking forward to the follow-up.

thanks for writing abt this. infuriating allegations

Barbara Mazor says:

Thank you for writing this. I had been following the war closely and was quite surprised to read Carr’s column because I had read about terrorist operatives using journalists for cover. Carr complains that the media building was attacked. But Islamic Jihad confirmed to AFP that Ramez Harb, a senior commander in its armed wing, the Al-Quds Brigades, was killed in the attack. So glad to see this issue taken up by a real publication.

Ean Seeb says:

Thank you Adam.

Of course, some people slap “The New York Times” on their byline and pretend to be journalists.

Daniel P says:

What is your source that the alleged journalist Hussam Salama described in the Carr article is the same person as the senior Hamas member Muhammed Shamalah? The IDF blog that you link to doesn’t say anything about Hussam Salama.

ginzy1 says:

“But what about the truth?”

Since when is “truth” relevant at the NY Times, in particular when it doesn’t fit their established “frame” (

The Times has long suffered from an intellectual honesty deficit and Carr is merely another link in that hoary tradition.


J’lem / Efrata

haggadah says:

I think that Chandler’s attack
on Carr is way too facile. Truth is that most journalists are partisans
in one way or another. An American journalist (whether “MSM” or not)
embedded with a U.S. Army unit is obviously partisan, but the “rules of
war” still say that s/he is not fair game, especially if traveling in a
vehicle marked “press” or “TV” or whatever. Undoubtedly the Taliban
would disagree and kill anyway, if they got the chance. It’s certainly
not great PR for Israel to adopt that line. Ironically, one reason
Israel got better press in this Gaza war than in the last one was that
they did allow journalists in — last time they banned all journalists,
leaving the only news from Gaza in the hands of partisans. But choosing
to assassinate these three was, I think, a bad mistake. Carr is the messenger, not the one at fault.

    Saint_Etienne says:

    I think you’ve got the wrong analogy. The two men mentioned by name in the article were not journalists embedded with the Hamas – rather, they were apparently active-duty militants who also dabbled in writing (and that’s taking, the charitable view – has anyone ever read an article by any one of them? most likely, they were just using the TV wagon for protection, the way they’d normally use a Red Cross vehicle or any other guise). Fair game.

I don’t for one second believe that he “bit”. I believe he, as a loyal NYT reporter sought a a tag, and provided what the anti-Israel NYT wanted. And a big ditto to Tablet for exposing the lies.

PhillipNagle says:

I find it hard to believe that Carr’s errors were not deliberate. Even a cub reporter knows enough not to make those types of errors. The New York Times has turned itself into an anti Israel propaganda sheet and Carr was just doing his job as a good employee.

Chuck Stamford says:

Can someone point out to me a significant difference in the content of a “news” article written by David Carr, and the content of a radio broadcast by “Tokyo Rose”, “The Nightingale of Nanking”, “Little Margie”, and other radio propagandists during WWII?

Laura Dailey says:

Please review the Hard Drive Video concerning Nasa MD Elizabeth Stallings,Charles,Kathy Stallings,Trisha,Caroline,Jason Levonaveseye,David Fisher,Marcus,Richard Devoreze,Mark Mendeze,Jay,Tina Theavor,Sheila,Ray Berkshirer,Richard Pheleseyeze,Robert Parson,Kristin Johnson,Carrie Snyder,Alan Planker,Mark Dunthers,Kathy Shoester,Lashawnda White,Kristin & Max Dunnigan,Jason Mayson,Cara Shipley,Richard Cortez,Wierdly Family,Betty,Jimmy Hendricks,Kristin,Jenny,Ray Farmer,Charles Manor,Vince Langley,Jason Bell,Tracey Lewis,Cherly Degrazion,Patricia White,Edward Stewart,Richard Stephen,Shannon Miller,Susan Sandler,Jenny White,Rick Trueman,Birchremeze,Suvarfereze,Davenporter,Tim Backman,Trisha Kelsey,Bluca Family,Ron,Tina Foster,Kristin Berkley,Tina,Robert Faye,Robert Paliciale,Ray,Jenny Smith,Alexandra Deferoneses,Barenoseo’s-Moon History..After the Elizabeth Stallings Bombing 7 Secret Service of MD & The Mayor (Phanton) in the Hallway..Secret Service Phanton..Etc Heather Panlaski,Stacey Edwards,Jenny Myers,Vicki,Tina Stone,Jenny Fry,Amanda Schaffer,Casey Aronald,Huff,Lastrosteo..Set Up False..Search the State of MD’s Machines for the Following Codes: 1307,1836,1820,1926,1912,1019,1012,1436,1312,1837,1480,1015,2460,1010,1314,1212,1813,1219..I was never asked to appear in Court against Elizabeth Stallings because she bombed the state with other Terrorist besides my house 320 Montpelier Ct Westminster Md 21157.My family was never Refunded for any Damages.


Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Times Mistakes Gaza Terrorists For Journalists

David Carr makes a huge reporting mistake

More on Tablet:

Why the Teenage Girls of Europe Are Joining ISIS

By Lee Smith — Because they want the same things that teenage boys want: a strong sense of meaning and purpose