Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another


Putin, Israel, Pressure, And America

You know, little things.

Print Email
Photo of an Ilyushin IL-76, a Russian plane used to put out fires in Israel.(By Flavio/Flickr.)

Dan noted this morning at Daybreak that the Russian President was stopping by Jerusalem for a chat with Prime Minister Netanyahu. Walter Russell Mead, picking up on some recent arms dealing, spots a trend:

The shared interests of the two countries cover some important ground: they oppose Turkey’s ambition to become a regional hegemon, they distrust the Obama administration’s support of democracy even when that leads to Islamist regimes and they both fear the rise of Sunni Islamism as a dangerous and destabilizing force.

Additionally, the large influx of Russians into Israel after the fall of the Soviet Union creates strong human and business ties between the two countries. Both governments would like to see these ties, and especially the business connections, grow.

It’s an interesting binational connection, one that should worry you if you’re the sort that thinks the U.S. could pressure Israel into behaving on the settlement issue if only Congress would cooperate. Look closely at Mead’s speculation about Putin-Netanyahu dialogue:

Putin will find this a refreshing conversation; unlike American diplomats and their talk of universal principles and global order, it’s likely that the Israelis will speak the language of national interests that Putin prefers.

The unstated implication is that Bibi will find a conversation free of human rights discourse equally refreshing. What this suggests is that Washington’s ability to pressure Israel is directly dependent on the degree to which Israel relies on American financial and political support. Cut Israel off completely and it’ll find new friends, perhaps ones less interested in nudging Israel towards a deal with its Arab neighbors. It’s true that those new friends might not support Israel as fully as the U.S. does, but it’s not clear that this discrepancy would be enough to force Israel to accede to American terms. Thus, even in a hypothetical world of a completely compliant Congress and President, it’s not remotely obvious that cutting Israel off would make a peace deal more likely. It could even have the opposite effect. Better instead to think creatively about how America can use its special relationship with Israel than to fantasize about an impossible world where the relationship didn’t exist.

Russian President Putin to visit Israel, West Bank and Jordan [LA Times]

Russia-Israel Rapprochement? [The American Interest]

Print Email
Cool_Romeo says:

This is so logical and mature in recognizing that Israel is an independent state actor that must look out for its own state interests.

So nice to know that Sullivan’s mania isn’t contagious.

yevka says:

Avigdor Lieberman and Vladimir Putin have a lot of ugly things in common.

yitzhakhizkiya says:

Allies and friends come in many sizes and colours. Some truer and others less. In my view, the US have only one true ally in the ME: Israel. The question is if the Muslim states can ever grow to have such close relations. The further question would be if the US earnestly understand that Israel is a sovereign state with its very own and a lot more different agenda. Presidents can come and go as visitors. Ex-PMs can do the same.
Still, Israel must be free to be the master of its own life.
Consequently, all who are interested in the region should come with an open mind and not with views and attitudes made at home. That goes for the US, Russia, the UN, the EU and China; great players all of them but only israel is Israel in Israel.

PhillipNagle says:

This is what happens when the US continually undermines Israel’s postion in dealings with the arabs. Israel, with 200 nuclear war heads, is forced to look for freinds elsewhere. Israel and the Assad regime of Syria may reach a peace agreement with Russian help.


Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Putin, Israel, Pressure, And America

You know, little things.

More on Tablet:

Rediscovering the First Woman Rabbi

By Laura Geller — Ordained in 1935, Regina Jonas died at Auschwitz. Now, she’s being honored.