Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

We Tried to Warn Obama

Rabbi Michael Lerner emails to call out the president, in the cause of tikkun olam

Print Email
(Vanessa Davis)

The Emails of Zion is a collection of messages from Jewish parents, uncles, aunts, grandparents, and others who are eager—often way too eager—to inform their children about issues of pressing concern to the Jewish community. Some of these emails may sound crazy, paranoid, ethnocentric, and/or racist, while others are disturbingly sane. These are the voices of our elders, lightly edited and presented for the convenience of their progeny, who are often too busy to write back.

Forward emails from your elders to

———- Forwarded message ———-
FROM: [A relative]
Subject: RE: We tried to warn Obama…but he wouldn’t listen
Date: January 20, 2010 7:05:03 AM EST
To: [Rabbi Michael Lerner]
Cc: [Tablet Magazine]

Obama prays on a Moslem prayer rug five times a day facing Mecca. He is often joined in holy prayer by Emmanuel Rahm and David Axelrod, Pritzker and Soros. He answers to the call of the Muahdin from Saudi Arabia. He obviously wasn’t praying hard enough yesterday. The Republican won the Massachusetts senate seat.

Why do I think that I will be removed from any future Tikkun emails?

———- Forwarded message ———-
From: Rabbi Michael Lerner
Sent: Wednesday, January 20, 2010 2:32 AM
To: [Distribution list]
Subject: We tried to warn Obama… but he wouldn’t listen. The result can be seen in Massachusetts’ Senate election

We Tried to Warn Obama… But He Wouldn’t Listen
By Rabbi Michael Lerner January 19, 2010

The defeat of the Democrats choice to succeed Ted Kennedy in the U.S. Senate is being treated as though there is a decided shift of mass opinion to the Right in the U.S. But it is the Obama Administration, not the people who supported him in 2008, which moved to the Right—in the name of being pragmatists or realists—in the process emptying their own agenda in regard to health care, environment, human rights, social and economic justice, and global peace of the critical elements that made those programs sound hopeful, and leaving many of their supporters feeling confused, disillusioned, and unable to rally around the politics that seemed so very far from “the change you can believe in” that we had been promised.

Thousands of us saw this coming, and tried to warn Obama, but he wouldn’t listen.

On April 29, 2009, Tikkun and our education arm the Network of Spiritual Progressives bought the entire back page of a special supplement published in the Washington Post on the occasion of the 100th day of Obama’s presidency. We warned him that his presidency was in grave danger. Our point was simple and direct: “Your success depends on helping people believe that they can count on each other, that they are not alone in a ruthless world in which people are out for themselves, and there is a possibility of building a society based on kindness, generosity, and caring for each other. Unless your programs actually allow people to feel in their own lives that they are part of build a new society based on love and generosity of spirit, they will soon fall back into the older paranoid view-that we are all competing with each other and have to look our first for number one. And that will likely them right back into the hands of the most conservative forces in this society. It’s that simple….”


Our add went on to tell President Obama that his supporters were beginning to feel mobilized because they cannot explain to themselves and others:

* Why you are bailing out the bankers and the Wall Street crowd rather than prioritizing the needs of people who have lost their jobs and homes
* Why you are not backing single payer (Medicare for Everyone) health reform but are instead preserving the interests of the health care profiteers and insurance companies that make our health care system so costly
* Why you are escalating the war in Afghanistan and Pakistan, when you must know that these are no win situations, and when you have even agreed with Rabbi Michael Lerner that the best way to achieve “homeland security” is not by attempting to dominate others around the world in an insane “war on terrorism,” but instead by a Strategy of Generosity manifested in the Network of Spiritual Progressives’ proposal for a Global Marshal Plan introduced into the Congress by Congressman Keith Ellison
* Why you have failed to bring into your Administration more leaders of the peace, social justice, labor and environmental movements that gave you the critical support you needed to win the Democratic nomination for President.

Our conclusion: “If the people who made your presidency possible stop feeling excited about your present direction, the populist energies that could be mobilized for fundamental change will instead by mobilized by the Right for reactionary goals, and you may find yourself without the base of support you need even for your scaled down goals.” And now our worst fears and prophetic predictions are coming true. If you were one of the many members of the Network of Spiritual Progressives or subscribers to Tikkun who donated to make the ad we published possible, I want to thank you for your ability to see what was ahead—and your willingness to back your wisdom with the money we needed to publish that ad!


Obama could have spoken the truth, told what he saw happening in Washington rather than trying to be a clever inside manipulator—a game that he was destined to lose. Any legislative victory won by compromising away the heart of what you are fighting for isn’t worth much, and in any event, even good legislation can quickly be dismantled by the next president if you haven’t won over the minds and hearts of the American people—and to do that you need to speak the truth and tell people what we are up against in the system of global capital and its ethos of materialism, selfisness, and looking-out-for-number-one, and what it would take to dismantle it and replace that system with a more humane and caring, environmentally sane and ethically and spiritually coherent society. And Obama could have constantly reminded his supporters that the 2008 election had shown that their yearning for a world of peace and justice, of love and caring and community and real solidarity and democracy, were not the private dreams of an isolated minority but the real needs of the American majority. By making us visible to each other, he would have empowered people to fight for programs that manifested their highest values (if and only if his programs did in fact manifest those values, which unfortunately they often did not).

Now it’s up to us, the tens of millions of Americans who really showed in 2008 the powerful commitment we have to building a world of love, kindness, generosity, environmental sanity and caring for others….

Please don’t let your disappointment at Obama lead you or your friends into political passivity … because the alternative if you do that is Sarah Palin and The Tea Party extremists and the haters and fundamentalists, all of whom are now momentarily dressing themselves in the language of populism, but all of whom will actually only give even more power to the elites of wealth and power.

That’s why it is so important for you to become part of our efforts to reconstitute the movement of hope—and we can do that with your help. We need your ideas and involvement—and so we’ve created two conferences, a one day event on the Monday of President’s Day weekend, February 15, at the McLaren Hall on the campus of the University of San Francisco on Fulton St. near Clayton; and a longer event June 11-14 at the Church of the Reformation on Capitol Hill in Washington D.C. The conferences are co-sponsored by The Nation Magazine, Yes Magazine, Democracy Now, Op-ed News, Peace Action,, the Buddhist Peace Fellowship, and speakers will include Chris Hedges, Bill McKibben, David Korten, Congressman Keith Ellison, Riane Eisler, Rev. Brian McLaren, Benedictine Sister Joan Chittister, Peter Gabel, Rev. James Winkler, Rev. Conrad Braaten, Robert Thurman, Rabbi Arthur Waskow, Rev. Gralan Hagler, Rabbi Arthur Waskow, Jonathan Granoff, Marianne Williamson, Paul Wapner, John Dear SJ, John Nichols, Svi Shapiro, Bob McChesney, Rabbi Michael Lerner, and many more.

Please register for one of these conferences now at (to plan effectively, we need to know very soon if you’ll be coming!) If you cannot come, please donate to make it possible for us to afford to create these events (the amount we are charging will not even come close to covering our expenses: donate on-line at or by sending a check to Tikkun, 2342 Shattuck Ave,#1200, Berkeley, Ca. 94704).

Print Email

Daily rate: $2
Monthly rate: $18
Yearly rate: $180

Tablet is committed to bringing you the best, smartest, most enlightening and entertaining reporting and writing on Jewish life, all free of charge. We take pride in our community of readers, and are thrilled that you choose to engage with us in a way that is both thoughtful and thought-provoking. But the Internet, for all of its wonders, poses challenges to civilized and constructive discussion, allowing vocal—and, often, anonymous—minorities to drag it down with invective (and worse). Starting today, then, we are asking people who'd like to post comments on the site to pay a nominal fee—less a paywall than a gesture of your own commitment to the cause of great conversation. All proceeds go to helping us bring you the ambitious journalism that brought you here in the first place.

Readers can still interact with us free of charge via Facebook, Twitter, and our other social media channels, or write to us at Each week, we’ll select the best letters and publish them in a new letters to the editor feature on the Scroll.

We hope this new largely symbolic measure will help us create a more pleasant and cultivated environment for all of our readers, and, as always, we thank you deeply for your support.

Argaman says:

Jeeez, this is unfair, we have to pick between yer loony uncle and Michael Lerner? I don’t want the Network of Spiritual Progressives to be running the government any more than I want someone who thinks Obama and Rahm Emanuel pray together towards Mecca five times a day! (What an image…)

Jeff Carpenter says:

add Sojourners org. to your list of spiritual progressives, if not on already.

David Star says:

Why am I not surprised? Michael (he calls himself Jewish) Lerner and Kieth Ellison in bed together. Now if only they can get JStreet onto their list, they can all bow down to their Messiahs-George Soros and Saudi King Fahd.

Jeremiah says:

from AIPAC: “As part of his $3.8 trillion budget request to Congress for fiscal year 2011, President Obama has asked for $3 billion in military aid to Israel-a $225 million increase from fiscal year 2010.” Apparently, not praying to Mecca hard enough.

Carolynn Davis says:

Dear Rabbi Lerner, I do not know why you think people in the tea party movement are hateful. I am one of those people and I know many like myself. We do not hate anyone but we do hate what is happening to our country. We are believers in the Constitution and desire to live by it. We also want less government, which was the original plan for this country, not the massive liberal govt which is devouring us of all our rights and our ability to live as individuals. Political correctness has brought us to our knees in every area of our lives even our homes! Please explain what is wrong with any of this. I am 65 years old and remember this country when it was not under so much control although it has been moving in that direction for as long as I have been alive. And I have been taking a stand for it that long. If you wish to question my educational level I have several degrees including post-graduate. Hopefully my faith in God is not offensive to you because that would reveal that those like yourself have hateful thoughts towards me. I pray that is not true as I pray for Israel and her people.

Strategy of Generosity??? Global Marshall Plan??? Spiritual Progessives??? All of that sounds a lot more sinister than people who prefer less government intrusion and lower taxes.

And you are calling Sarah Palin and Tea Party participants the “extremists?” Think again. The real extremists are people like you and the U.S. leadership who want to bankrupt America and leave a federal deficit that will enable the U.S. to be taken over by China, Russia, Japan, and Dubai. I wonder what will happen to Israel and the Jews when your enemies take control of your best ally? Why are so many American Jews pushing for the destruction of America?

One of these days you will learn that it was the so-called progressives (i.e., communists and marxists) who sold us out to the global elitists. It will not be done by the people you are bashing. Get your heads out of the sand and learn the truth now, before it’s too late.

Gerry Garber says:

Michael Lerner the so called “Rabbi” is a fake. I am surprised that Tablet has given him publicity.

Barack Obama’s book, “The Audacity of Hope,” provides a catchy title. It has an idea of bravery mixed with confidence. You’ll find nothing Pollyanna about that. I would possibly not support every little thing he says, but he’s our president, as well as for me, he inspires confidence. That can do more for any country than any number of backroom deals. Hope gives us energy, and energy sustains us through trying times. Boy, we’ve had them. I’m from West Texas, and I did not vote for Bush. When McCain ran against Obama, I used to be a citizen of Arizona, but I gave audacious hope a chance. The fight for progress and laying the foundations of prosperity isn’t over. I have come across the quips of those who don’t believe Obama is capable of doing it. But step back a second. Would anyone have most of us fail simply to tarnish the star of an incumbent for whom they did not vote? Attempting to keep our priorities straight, let’s work together with this president and build our future.

Christian Zionist says:

Lerner speaks only for himself, not for American Jews or American Zionists.

when it comes to tv fashion shows, i really love Project Runway because it shows some new talents in the fashion industry?id

I only want to say the way incredibly impressed My group is with the speed of this shipments. I am a brand new customer, and have now ordered a few different times Using USPS meant for shipping, I been given my very first package throughout 4 a short time, and the majority of impressively – I ordered the 2nd time on the Friday in addition to received our package around the following Saturday! Besides using a great variety, prices, and task suggestions, this has got made me a buyer for life!!

I do agree with all of the ideas you’ve presented in your postThey are very convincing and will certainly workStill, the posts are very short for newbiesCould you please extend them a bit from next time? Thanks for the post.


Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

We Tried to Warn Obama

Rabbi Michael Lerner emails to call out the president, in the cause of tikkun olam

More on Tablet:

A Tale of Three Twitter Feeds: Hamas Tweets in Arabic, English, and Hebrew

By Aaron Magid — Analysis of the social-media messaging of Hamas’ military wing reveals distinct voices for the West, the Arab Middle East, and Israel