Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

Etrog Man

California citrus farmer John Kirkpatrick, a Presbyterian well-versed in Jewish agricultural law, is the only large-scale grower of etrogs in the U.S.

Print Email
John Kirkpatrick and his wife, Shirley, on their farm in 2010. (Susie Wyshak/Flickr)
Related Content

Shaken Up

Egypt’s politically expedient ban on the export of palm fronds has altered the lulav market in unexpected ways

Growing etrogs is a difficult business. Too much sun and the yellow skin of the citrus fruit will burn; too little sun and the flowers won’t blossom. There’s infestation to worry about—red citrus mites are particularly fond of them. And then there are the religious prohibitions; blemishes render the fruit, a citron in English, useless for Sukkot, so if a branch or leaf pierces the skin of the etrog, you’re in trouble.

But John Kirkpatrick, a third-generation citrus farmer in California’s San Joaquin Valley, has overcome these obstacles and more. He’s the only large-scale grower of etrogs in the United States.

The octogenarian Kirkpatrick, who grows lemons, tangelos, and oranges in addition to etrogs on some 50 acres, is a Presbyterian. He knew almost nothing about the fruit when he was approached with an unusual business proposal more than 30 years ago. “It’s been a cultural trip for us—I’m Christian, but I now understand an awful lot about halakhic law,” Kirkpatrick said, using the Hebrew word for Jewish law, “as it relates to agriculture.”

In the fall of 1980, Kirkpatrick got a call from Yisroel Weisberger, “an Orthodox Jewish boy who worked in a Judaicia store in Brooklyn,” the farmer said. Weisberger, who also held a part-time job in a customs house handling etrog imports from Israel, was interested in finding a way to grow the fruit in America. Each Sukkot, Jews are commanded to shake the arba minim, or four species—the etrog and lulav, as well as willow and myrtle branches—to celebrate the holiday. (These days, a set of the four typically sells for $40, with the etrog the most expensive component, but can cost up to $150, depending on where it’s from. Most etrogs are imported from Israel, Italy, and Morocco.) Producing and selling them here had the potential to be a lucrative business.

But first Weisberger needed a farmer. He had heard of Kirkpatrick, a well-established citrus farmer—back then he was chairman of the Citrus Research Board—and hoped Kirkpatrick might refer him to a suitable grower. They spoke for an hour, and Kirkpatrick grew fascinated by the history and culture of the etrog, which he knew little about. “I had read about them in a five-volume set about citrus fruit,” he recalled, but he’d never seen one. Over the course of the conversation, Kirkpatrick became “convinced by the attractive-sounding value of the fruit,” as he put it. “You’ve already found your man,” he said when Weisberger asked him for some names. “And from there it was onward and upwards.”

John Kirkpatrick’s etrog orchard. (Susie Wyshak/Flickr)

Success didn’t come easy. “I found out that although I’m an expert citrus grower, I was not an expert etrog grower,” Kirkpatrick said. “It’s easier to grow 2,000 acres of oranges or lemons than to grow one acre of etrogs.” A friend of Weisberg’s helped them acquire plants from an Israeli grove, but the first few years were particularly tough. In the beginning, they produced “mediocre fruit that sold on street for $2 or $3 a piece,” Kirkpatrick said.

Unlike the other fruit Kirkpatrick grew, etrogs came with an additional set of rules. “It requires understanding of halakhah,” Kirkpatrick said. The lineage of each etrog tree must be certified, and the fruit can’t be grown on grafted or budded trees. Rabbinical supervision is required.

Kirkpatrick knows his Jewish religious terminology, at least as it pertains to etrogs. He recounted the differing opinions about the necessity of pitoms, or stems, to be intact to qualify the fruit as “complete.” And he explained that his business began to turn around in 1987, “when we got to our first shmita” —the last year in the seven-year agricultural cycle mandated by the Torah as a year of rest—“and had a pretty good year.” (In 1995 Weisberger got his brother-in-law Yaakov Shlomo Rothberg involved, and he has since taken over as Kirkpatrick’s partner.)

While Kirkpatrick was gregarious during an initial phone conversation, he declined to speak on further attempts to contact him. In the 2010 Encyclopedia of Jewish Food, Gil Marks writes about Kirkpatrick’s etrogs and reports that he has about 250 etrog trees on his farm, with his orchards producing approximately 3,000 etrogs a year suitable for use on Sukkot; some 9,000 don’t qualify.

David Wiseman, the owner of Zaide Reuven’s Esrog Farm, a Dallas-based distributor of the four species, has been buying etrogs from Kirkpatrick for 13 years. “They produce excellent quality, and are honest, honest people,” Wiseman said. “It’s a pleasure to work with people who know what they’re doing,” Wiseman’s etrogs sell together with lulavs for between $50 and $130. “John is very knowledgeable about the Jewish laws and concerned that he fulfills all the details of the Jewish laws,” Wiseman said. “If anything, he’s more stringent than he needs to be.”

And what happens to all that fruit that doesn’t make the grade? Etrogs that ripen and can’t be used for Sukkot, Kirkpatrick explained, end up being sold to greengrocers, manufacturers of marmalade, and, most frequently, the makers of citron-infused vodka—opening the distinct possibility that some of his etrogs are enjoyed year-round.

Print Email

Daily rate: $2
Monthly rate: $18
Yearly rate: $180

Tablet is committed to bringing you the best, smartest, most enlightening and entertaining reporting and writing on Jewish life, all free of charge. We take pride in our community of readers, and are thrilled that you choose to engage with us in a way that is both thoughtful and thought-provoking. But the Internet, for all of its wonders, poses challenges to civilized and constructive discussion, allowing vocal—and, often, anonymous—minorities to drag it down with invective (and worse). Starting today, then, we are asking people who'd like to post comments on the site to pay a nominal fee—less a paywall than a gesture of your own commitment to the cause of great conversation. All proceeds go to helping us bring you the ambitious journalism that brought you here in the first place.

Readers can still interact with us free of charge via Facebook, Twitter, and our other social media channels, or write to us at Each week, we’ll select the best letters and publish them in a new letters to the editor feature on the Scroll.

We hope this new largely symbolic measure will help us create a more pleasant and cultivated environment for all of our readers, and, as always, we thank you deeply for your support.

Fascinating piece!

I wonder why he refused follow-up conversations.

Bill Pearlman says:

Great story

This piece is Tablet at its best.

Carolyn Geiger says:

I’ve been successful growing etrogs from seed. I have the trees in pots. I harvested my first fruit 2 days ago–just in time for Sukkot!! The same tree has 2 small, green fruits that are getting larger every day. They will be for next year, I guess. I have about 50 seedlings in 1-gallon pots that I will soon be transplanting to much larger containers.

Way to go! And, thank-you.

Hello men In my opinion this is a great publish I’ll definetely keep up reading your works, well done. It is crucial to have high quality contents on the web, we are able to use them like a reliable source for the projects.Ive see clearly along with pleasure as well as Im sure Im gonna read all the other things you may create, great job man!.

welcomerman says:

You have all my congratulations.Please,i m verry interested.I’m from morocco and i can assure  you that i know this fruit about 30years ago since i was a little child ,oh yes. I ‘ve a verry long and sad story with it.It  has affected my hole  life .this is my email.; contact me.and you ll know all tue story.then you can understand. my best regards and respect to you and you wife.thank you for your time

welcomerman says:

i m still waiting for answear please.thank you

lieselg says:

Bought two etrog bushes from a coastal CA gardener which were mowed down by idiots at home and at my temple. Tried again and the third, hidden from the gardener by a barricade of spiny blood oranges, was hit by a hard frost which revealed it had been grafted. It produced one (1) fruit which is now in my spice box. I was just aiming for a biblical garden since I live in the world’s second-best place for one, not to supplant the Israeli vendors. At least my olive tree, planted 37 years ago, is, like my pomegranate, bearing for my grandchildren to enjoy. Nice article. Please stop printing anything and everything submitted to you.

kosherchorizo says:

one of the problems of Etrogim is you CANNOT grow them around other citrus; at all. the cross polination from any other species of citrus, even if it is many miles away and only a small amount has traveled, will warm the fruit and plant beyond repair. this makes growing them in California very hard as we are covered with citrus fruits, especially oranges and lemons. its best to grow them in a canyon, but still you must be far from any other citrus for miles

Brian Kunzelmann says:


I enjoyed your article about John. I am looking forward to getting my first fruit from him sometime in the next month or so. I have never had fresh etrogs. So, as you can imagine, I am quite excited. I will be using them to make candied citron for fruit cake. I make every year. This will be the first time I am making the candied fruit myself.

Elisse says:

I am looking to buy at least one etrog tree (preferably Israeli) I had 6 that I’d grown from seed from an Israeli etrog and they were truly precious to me! They were 3 years old and about 4′ high, but all died this winter when our greenhouse failed, and I can’t find them anywhere. :-( Can you help?
Thanks! Elisse email: elisse(at)

How wonderful that you are growing citron trees!
Would you please sell one to me? I would like one to grow in our greenhouse. (in Pacific Grove, CA)


Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Etrog Man

California citrus farmer John Kirkpatrick, a Presbyterian well-versed in Jewish agricultural law, is the only large-scale grower of etrogs in the U.S.

More on Tablet:

A Tale of Three Twitter Feeds: Hamas Tweets in Arabic, English, and Hebrew

By Aaron Magid — Analysis of the social-media messaging of Hamas’ military wing reveals distinct voices for the West, the Arab Middle East, and Israel