Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

Elijah’s Plate

Facing my first Christmas alone in decades and volunteering at a nearby soup kitchen, I discovered an unexpected and enveloping community

Print Email
(Ethan Miller/Getty Images)

Last year, after 29 Christmases with my Jewish, tree-decorating, stocking-stuffing, carol-singing in-laws, I realized I’d be alone for Christmas. These things happen, my friend Zena, the Euripides scholar said. (If you want the long view, ask a classicist.)

The last time I was alone for Christmas, I had to be told it was a problem. It was 1979, and I was living in a cold, damp flat in West London, earning a pittance in publishing. When a colleague asked about my plans for Christmas, I said I had none. “Poor dear,” she exclaimed, “alone for Christmas. We won’t have that!” I kept to myself that I had never before celebrated Christmas. Two days later, I hopped aboard the family “dormobile,” a VW microbus with mattresses on the floor instead of seats. The kids—Annabelle, Natasha, Tristram—and I slept in our coats and woke up in Inverness. We stayed in a hunting lodge heated (imperceptibly) by an Aga stove in the kitchen and lit by a whining generator that was powered down at bedtime. Christmas Eve we trekked across the moor to a small cabin—a Scottish shtibl—and sang carols with the local crofters. Christmas day, we baked a Christmas cake full of sultanas, popped Christmas “crackers” (a wrapped tube that snaps open like a cap gun), and took the Guardian’s Christmas Quiz. Christmas night I warmed myself with Glenfiddich, a hot-water bottle, and a novel about sweltering Rhodesians. So this was Christmas: dark by 3 p.m., bone-cold, but otherwise not bad, not bad at all.

Thirty years later, I’m alone for Christmas, and I know it. I ponder a solitary afternoon of chow fun and Meryl Streep, and I decide I won’t have it. Instead, I sign up to work at Elijah’s Promise, a nearby soup kitchen, in a basement in New Brunswick, New Jersey.

When I arrive, I’m hurried off to wash my hands, issued a hairnet and plastic apron, and told to find Felipe, “the guy in the red apron.” He’s a stocky guy with a biker’s swagger and a wide, open smile; among the volunteers, an eminence. His charges are me and Gwendolyn, a lithe, black 20-something with amber eyes. She seems embarrassed by her beauty, like a swan caught becoming a woman.

Felipe explains our task. At noon, when the doors open, the line of people waiting out in the cold will file in. (Pairs of legs, hopping to keep warm, can be seen through the basement windows.) Each client, as the patrons are called, will take a carnival ticket and sit in front of a red or green placemat adorned with snowmen, candy canes, and Bible verses scrawled in a child’s cursive hand. Our job is to serve them dinner. Like school kids on a lunch line, we’re to present our trays to the women of the missionary club of the First Baptist Church of Carteret, who will portion out the turkey dinner—with green beans, sweet potato, gravy, and cranberry sauce—the women spent Christmas Eve preparing.

“If they ask for seconds?” I ask.

“Sometimes they do, but most don’t stick around,” Felipe says. “Some of them eat and run to catch the shuttle to the other soup kitchens in town, they go from one Christmas dinner to another.” He shrugs, amused. “Ya can’t blame them.” The cohort of volunteers has swelled, most of them African-American: a grizzled 75-year-old man, a tall dad with two skinny-jeaned teenage daughters, assorted able-bodied young men, one goateed like a calendar Confucius. The only other white person is a well-heeled petite woman in a chunky cable sweater. She’s Jewish, and I think I know what she’s doing here—repairing the world where it’s caving in. But how many of those here are alone for Christmas, like me, without husbands, wives, parents, children?

Felipe has left us to join a woman with a reporter’s pad at a nearby table. Apparently he’s not just the majordomo; he’s also the press secretary. But Gwendolyn knows the drill. “The hungriest folks will wave their tickets in the air,” she says. “Serve them first. See that everyone at the table is served at the same time. And don’t bus their plates; they have to do that themselves.”

While we wait for the stroke of noon, we place a platter of pie—slices of pumpkin, pecan, and pineapple—on each table, then pour 80 paper cups of V8 juice. One of the skinny-jeaned teens sticks out her tongue in disgust “V8?” “Never mind,” says one of the Carteret ladies. “It’s filling and nutritious. It’s almost soup.”

At noon, the doors open, and the line of people slowly slithers in. I ask myself if, out on the street, I could peg these people as Elijah’s clients. The answer, for nine out of 10, is yes. Many are elderly and move slowly; they walk with difficulty, as though back pain is a fact of daily life, not a cause for steroid shots and acupuncture. Several are missing front teeth, and here and there are cheeks with open sores. The men tend to be unshaven; the women look more kempt, and a few sport silver and green Christmas beads. Some are both hungry and obese, which is perhaps why there are diabetes information posters on the walls, in English and Spanish. And many, more than I want to admit, have a withdrawn, absent look that means—what? That they’re resigned to life on the bottom? Or that fate has consigned them to the limbo of their minds?

A clutch of teens from a nearby Hindu temple appear out of nowhere, giving each client a wrapped, ribboned gift, a pair of gloves, and a scarf. “Let us bow our heads!” bellows an elder of the First Baptist Church, then he mumbles a speedy grace. The Hindu teens, as if on cue, begin to sing “Rudolf the Red-Nosed Reindeer,” reading the lyrics off their Blackberrys. Singing along are four siblings ranging in age from 3 to 8, the only little kids in evidence. Two walked in with winter jackets, two did not; all are clad in Gymboree castoffs of aqua and pepto-bismol pink. Presently trays arrive for them with plates of baked ziti, not turkey; they’re vegetarians. While mom runs off in search of missing napkins, spoons, juice, dad hovers to make sure they finish their food.

It turns out Gwendolyn was wrong. The hungriest are not the ticket-wavers. The hungriest are the ones who sit down and tear into the pie on the table. One woman drains a styrofoam cup of water and begins stuffing it with pumpkin pie; the pie’s to go. I bring a plate of food to a man in a black overcoat whose placemat has verses from scripture but no utensils. I’m starting to feel expansive, and put my hand on his shoulder. “You can’t eat string beans off the words of God,” I say, and offer to fetch utensils. “Fuggetit, darlin’,” he says broadly and plucks a fork from his overcoat pocket. Five minutes before closing, two stragglers arrive: an old man in an army jacket and a large woman lashed in scarves and bundled in three layers of coats. They’re not ticket-wavers; in fact, they keep their eyes on the table and speak to no one, so abject, they make the others look like game-show hosts.

It’s good to be busy, and I’m saying “Merry Christmas” to all comers, happy to be wished one in return. There’s a buzz of purpose and enthusiasm, at the tables, in the kitchen, among the ferrying volunteers. In fact, I’m starting to feel freilach, and not because it’s Christmas. It’s like being at the wedding of a beshert match: a hungry person, a steaming plate of food.

Felipe’s journalist is heading for the door, and Felipe returns to the lunch counter. He’s revved, a little anxious; whatever that interview was about, it didn’t go so well. “She heard that I’m the volunteer of the year, that I’m taking the culinary arts course,” he says. (Elijah’s Promise doesn’t only feed people; they train people to feed others.) “I told her I started coming here every day to give something back, but all she wanted to know about was how I ended up in prison. She smelled a story, but I wasn’t gonna talk about it. Those journalists, they seem interested, but they just wanna sell papers.”

“You have to be careful with journalists,” I tell him. “At least you have to make them read back the quotes.”

“I told her mainly I come here because I love the volunteers,” Felipe continues. “They just love doing what they do, taking care of these people. So what if some are just putting in hours for their community service?” I take a second, harder look, at my fellow volunteers—felons? Misdemeanants?— but all our crimes are expunged by the smell of ammonia. The goateed man stacks the chairs, and a guy with a bandana mops up. Gwendolyn and I wipe down tables. At each, two or three cups of V8 remain, uncouth, unkissed.

When I get home, I look up Elijah’s promise. It is not, as I’d assumed all day, a story about Jesus. It’s a promise to the starving Widow of Zarephath: “The jar of meal shall not be spent, neither shall the cruse of oil fail, until the day that the Lord sendeth rain upon the land.” (I Kings 17:14) It’s a promise of bread for those with a handful of meal, and oil for those who bear an empty cruse—a promise that, when the heart is cracked and dry, the God of Israel will notice.

Esther Schor, a poet and professor of English at Princeton University, is the author of
Emma Lazarus.

Print Email

Daily rate: $2
Monthly rate: $18
Yearly rate: $180

Tablet is committed to bringing you the best, smartest, most enlightening and entertaining reporting and writing on Jewish life, all free of charge. We take pride in our community of readers, and are thrilled that you choose to engage with us in a way that is both thoughtful and thought-provoking. But the Internet, for all of its wonders, poses challenges to civilized and constructive discussion, allowing vocal—and, often, anonymous—minorities to drag it down with invective (and worse). Starting today, then, we are asking people who'd like to post comments on the site to pay a nominal fee—less a paywall than a gesture of your own commitment to the cause of great conversation. All proceeds go to helping us bring you the ambitious journalism that brought you here in the first place.

Readers can still interact with us free of charge via Facebook, Twitter, and our other social media channels, or write to us at Each week, we’ll select the best letters and publish them in a new letters to the editor feature on the Scroll.

We hope this new largely symbolic measure will help us create a more pleasant and cultivated environment for all of our readers, and, as always, we thank you deeply for your support.

D. B. Starr says:

beautiful inside and out

This makes one think. baba

Wonderful story. Thanks for sharing.

Jay A Friedman says:

I feel for the writer.

You see, I never faced a Christmas alone.

Actually, I never faced a Christmas with anyone else.

As a matter of fact, I never faced a Christmas.

I’m Jewish

You are truly part of tikkun olam. I’m so proud to be related to you!

Thank you for a cup of warmth on a cold, cold day!

Very touching–it makes me want to help out at a soup kitchen.

To the author. See
במדבר כג:ט Numbers 23:9
(ט) כִּי מֵרֹאשׁ צֻרִים אֶרְאֶנּוּ וּמִגְּבָעוֹת אֲשׁוּרֶנּוּ הֶן עָם לְבָדָד יִשְׁכֹּן וּבַגּוֹיִם לֹא יִתְחַשָּׁב
I pity you. You do not have an existence on your own. I suppose you can get the translation in some library. I wish you many Dec/25, alone, in which you do not miss a soup-kitchen, but you miss your fellow brothers: us, Jews.

David Star says:

My eldest son, zt”l his wife and children worked annually at the Christmas meal for the poor associated with one of the local churches in their city in northern New York State.
He also leined Torah at least once a month in their congregation. He died 2 months before his 40th birthday.
At his funeral 17 years ago the funeral hall was filled to overflowing and a city police escort accompanied the almost 100 autos 17 miles to the cemetary.
His widow and 3 children continue the practice to this day along with other members of their shul who also have the Yiddishe Neshuma which calls upon us to help the downtrodden.

Cheryl says:

I think that to scorn this Jewish woman for trying to give hungry Christians something to eat on one of the most important days ofntheir year demonstrates a shocking lack of understanding of what charity really is. Through my local Jewish family service, my family helps to organize and Chanukah gifts for needy Jewish families as well as Christmas gifts for the many more needy Christian families. We don’t celebrate Christmas, but part of charity is recognizing what is important to the recipients, and that is important for our four year old daughter to learn. Mazel tov to this author for doing good and feeding the hungry in this world instead of going to the movies or eating Chinese food the way so many Jews do on Christmas.

Also, doesn’t make her a turncoat to Jews to recognize that her former family in law used to celebrate Christmas, and this has left a void in her life. To go from a time of huge family celebration to a time of emptiness is hard. To have embraced the food and companionship does not mean she celebrated Christmas in the religious sense. I’m ashamed on behalf of some self righteous Jewish commanders here who don’t seem to have room for a shred of empathy.

Ruth Gutmann says:

It is far more valuable to help out at a soup kitchen — no matter what religious group runs it — than sitting at home wallowing in self pity. I agree with Cheryl that reacting with self-righteousness is uncalled for and says more about the responder than about Prof. Schor.

Poignant, eloquent, poetic, wise, and generous. This is what charity is: a giving to others which, fortunately, can also fill a void in oneself. The idea that Jews should be generous only to Jews is just the mentality that gives us a world full of war and hatred. This article is written with and about love, in its strange and myriad forms, all of which are sacred to the God of Israel.

Esther Gynther says:

In this time of year I am the most happy to be Jewess. I live in country
which have a very strong christianity culture and christmas is the most high feast. Here in Finland the christmas is everywhere and in evrything. But there are many broken families, alcool problems, pouvrety and many people alone. It makes me feeling so sorry for all these people because I know that in christmas they suffer very much.
Nine years ago my son, 12 years old, died and since I feel me alone evry day but for me christmas is nothing so I am as alone as every
other day in the year. There is one moment that I don’t feel alone; when I light my Shabbat lights I feel me connected with all my Jews sisters and brohers in the world, this is my highest feast and it’s every week. We are very privileged.

Shalom Rav Sis, Great piece and great neshama. May Yom Ha-Molad (christmas…literally the day of the birth) be a re-birth for those on either side of the steam table. Early Shabbat Shalom, Josh

thank you esther such a moving and touching article

JackieFour says:

What a wonderful story. My day now has a song.

I’ve said that least 3071433 times. The problem this like that is they are just too compilcated for the average bird, if you know what I mean

Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can’t wait to read lots of your posts.

My brother recommended I might like this website. He was entirely right. This post actually made my day. You can not imagine just how much time I had spent for this information! Thanks!

I found the perfect place for my needs. Contains wonderful and useful messages. I have read most of them and has a lot of them. To me, he’s doing the great work.

I actually found your post you wrote intriguing; thank you very much and keep up the awesome work

Another issue of which on-line talking may existing is the self-confidence of your individual. As it will be less difficult to help communicate on the internet, someone who’s going to be really self conscious as well as shy could possibly have a hard time keeping up with who seem to he / she genuinely is usually. The individual as an alternative is similar to living the two oceans.

Thank you, Esther, for your moving words. Your open heart reveals itself so well, both in your choice of activities and in your ability to let in the warmth and light that is there. Freilach–I love it. Chag Sameach.


Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Elijah’s Plate

Facing my first Christmas alone in decades and volunteering at a nearby soup kitchen, I discovered an unexpected and enveloping community

More on Tablet:

A Tale of Three Twitter Feeds: Hamas Tweets in Arabic, English, and Hebrew

By Aaron Magid — Analysis of the social-media messaging of Hamas’ military wing reveals distinct voices for the West, the Arab Middle East, and Israel