Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another


A haftorah of strong emotions and long views

Print Email

Our youthful selves, it sometimes seems, exist in our minds primarily to mortify us. We inhabit the present, dignified and mature, when all of a sudden a wraith emerges from the bowels of the past and disturbs our subtle sophistication with an icy whisper of youthful folly.

A while back, to name but one terrifying example, a friend unearthed a letter I’d written a decade ago, in which I, impoverished and proud, extolled the virtues of a life unencumbered by material possessions. One glance at my current credit card statement would be enough to reveal that asceticism is a position I’ve long ago abandoned. As I read the letter, I couldn’t help but think that its author, most likely, would not have liked me. The feeling was mutual: Given the chance, I would shake Young Me as hard as I could in the hope that a good rattle would bring the poor, misguided fellow back to his senses.

And while I’ve come to dismiss many of my teenaged follies—from political persuasions to cultural predilections—there’s one particular conviction I’m not ready to forgo. I stumbled across it one drunken night in the 11th grade, having one of those shattering conversations about life and its deepest meanings most human beings are only capable of having in high school. My take on the meaning of life at 16 went something like this: I’d rather be hated than loved, because love is finicky and aimless but hate is earthly and concrete. We can’t always explain why we love the ones we love, I said then, but we frequently know why we hate the ones we hate. A rationalist, then, should aspire to be hated; at least then he’d have a better chance of being understood.

There are, needless to say, several serious flaws in this argument, but it’s not completely invalid. Isaiah himself raises a similar question in this week’s haftorah; describing the days of the Messiah, he promises Israel the usual material bounties, with one notable addition: “The children of your oppressors shall go to you bent over,” says the prophet, “and those who despised you shall prostrate themselves at the soles of your feet, and they shall call you ‘the city of the Lord, Zion of the Holy One of Israel.’ Instead of your being forsaken and hated without a passerby, I will make you an everlasting pride, the joy of every generation.”

To a discerning reader, this is a terrifying prospect. Jews, Isaiah is suggesting, would have to wait until the end of time for the world at large to abandon its hatred of God’s Chosen People. What, we may be excused for wondering, might we do in the meantime?

It’s a more profound question than it seems. If you take it at face value, it suggests one of two obvious paths: Until the Messiah comes, the Jews could strive to inspire love in a world prone to hate them, or they could seek strength in their persecution and construct an identity around their exclusion. Both options are disastrous. The first leads to weak-willed defeatism, the second to rank chauvinism. But there’s another way, the one hinted at by my sometimes sober younger self, the one that suggests we take comfort in being reviled.

On the surface, this is a nonsensical suggestion. Given the centuries of violence and persecution, there’s little soothing about the world’s systematic hatred of the Jews. But if we examine the roots of this ancient animosity, we’d likely find more than coiled rage and inchoate fear: For the most part, hatred of Jews draws its energies from the fact that Jews have fashioned for themselves an astonishing theological banner, declaring themselves to be the Almighty’s favorite sons. Things appear even more sinister if we try and ask what exactly it is that the Chosen People believe they were chosen for. At the height of the Biblical drama, when God rewards the Israelites with their exalted status, he gives little by way of details. The Israelites, he commands, should become a kingdom of priests and a holy nation. But why, and how, and toward what end—that the Lord leaves up to interpretation.

To some, Jews and non-Jews alike, this divine designation is understood as a claim to superiority and, accordingly, a mandate to act freely and without regard for those unchosen. Such an interpretation, I believe, disregards the terrible beauty at the heart of the matter. God, not usually one for ambiguity, remains vague on this gravely important matter because vagueness is the whole point. It’s this vagueness that propels those who believe themselves chosen to understand the idea of chosenness, and as they do so they transform their world in an effort to create a society more just and inspiring; as the chosen people struggle to come to terms with their spiritual reward, they end up entirely worthy of it. They understand their election to be what it truly is—a terrible burden, an exhortation to live up to more exacting standards, a demand for unceasing sacrifice—and yet they embrace it, ready to fulfill their historical role.

Seen in this light, a verdict of eternal hatred isn’t quite as horrific. It comes with the territory. In dreams, Delmore Schwartz famously put it, begin responsibilities; the same is true of nightmares.

Print Email

Daily rate: $2
Monthly rate: $18
Yearly rate: $180

Tablet is committed to bringing you the best, smartest, most enlightening and entertaining reporting and writing on Jewish life, all free of charge. We take pride in our community of readers, and are thrilled that you choose to engage with us in a way that is both thoughtful and thought-provoking. But the Internet, for all of its wonders, poses challenges to civilized and constructive discussion, allowing vocal—and, often, anonymous—minorities to drag it down with invective (and worse). Starting today, then, we are asking people who'd like to post comments on the site to pay a nominal fee—less a paywall than a gesture of your own commitment to the cause of great conversation. All proceeds go to helping us bring you the ambitious journalism that brought you here in the first place.

Readers can still interact with us free of charge via Facebook, Twitter, and our other social media channels, or write to us at Each week, we’ll select the best letters and publish them in a new letters to the editor feature on the Scroll.

We hope this new largely symbolic measure will help us create a more pleasant and cultivated environment for all of our readers, and, as always, we thank you deeply for your support.

J Carpenter says:

Loved or hated—God’s command is that we love him with all our heart, soul, intellect; we love our neighbors (all of them) as ourselves; that we seek justice, love mercy, and walk humbly with God; and that we be a light to the Gentiles. Loved or hated—but not ignored; he asks us to be faithful.
“The reward of a living a good life, is, a good life.”
Thanks for your articles; I look forward to them every week.

Shabbat shalom to you Liel and all at Tablet!
It’s from this broken and bowed position that we get a better view and understanding not specifically of just our place in the world i.e. the hated
But of how history must unravel itself before redemption.That’s my 2 pence worth!(I live in the UK)

Ah…..messianism and choseness – that’s a couple of interesting topics to sit together. We were chosen to be persecuted and suffer all these years just so we could wait for the messiah to come and do a whole-world makeover upon which we would exclaim, as in every home improvement show reveal, “Oh my God!” A bit of stretch, don’t you think?

If all of what Isaiah comes true, I would hope that we would have the grace to tell those that are bowed before us “It’s ok. Y’all can get up now. Let’s have a few beers tonight and tomorrow we’ll go to work together.

Eric Weis says:

Ah, yes, the Seventh Haftorah of Consolation poses a conundrum. When, exactly and under what circumstances will consolation come? Do people have any control, or do we simply wait and pray for a Messianic era of redemption which only the Infinite-One can bring about? I suppose the best we can do is to live a life of mitzvot (commanded good deeds) and remain hopeful in the face of eternal (?) persecution and chosen-ness. That model of conduct is the root of the covenant. And perhaps it explains why Am Yisrael remains, 3500 years or so after Sinai. So, as we approach the end of Elul and Tisha b’Av recedes, I wish Leil and all of the commenters, L’Shanah Tovah u’Metukah.

damn,you have a seriously twisted god on your hands, folks. Doomed to be hated forever by the untermensch?

“The children of your oppressors shall go to you bent over,”

Once, I met an Iraqi Christian. He actually identified himself as an Assyrian and promised that one day his nation will rid itself of its Arab occupation and be free “just like the Jews.”

Turns out our Assyrian captors have not fared so well over the years.

For that matter, our Greek former rulers are up to their eyeballs in debt.

Maybe Isiah was just saying “If you stick around long enough, every oppressor ends up getting oppressed by someone else.”

As for chosenness – I don’t see the problem. For people (Jews and non-Jews) who don’t believe in the Torah then these are simply words that can be ignored since they were written by someone 3500 years ago. For people who do believe in the Torah (Jews and non-Jews) then these are divine words and not to be questioned. Problem solved.


Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.


A haftorah of strong emotions and long views

More on Tablet:

Obama: Denying Israel’s Right to Exist as a Jewish Homeland is Anti-Semitic

By Yair Rosenberg — The president draws a line in the sand in his latest interview