Your email is not valid
Recipient's email is not valid
Submit Close

Your email has been sent.

Click here to send another

Dutch Treat

On the eve of his New York debut, an Amsterdam comedian reflects on Jewish funniness, the liberalism of the Netherlands, and Sarah Silverman. Plus a video preview.

Print Email
Micha Wertheim. (Merlijn Doomernik)

I am standing in front of the Soho Playhouse in Manhattan, at the corner of Sixth Avenue and Vandam Street, waiting for a signal to take a bite out of the big red apple I am holding in my right hand. A photographer thought it would be fun to take a picture of me taking a bite out of an apple in front of the Big Apple theater where I will be performing my one-man show later this week. It seems I have come all the way to New York only to be interviewed for a Dutch newspaper. With only eight tickets sold in advance, in a city that holds eight million potential buyers, I wonder how big my bite must be to do the metaphor justice.

After the picture is taken, Babette, who flew to New York to interview me, takes me to a café and asks what has made me decide to give up the comfort of Dutch theaters do a comedy show in a second language. So, I explain to her that most all my comic heroes are from the United States: Larry David, Garry Shandling, Woody Allen, Richard Pryor, Doug Stanhope, Jon Stewart,  Sarah Silverman—comedians who not only make you laugh but make you feel uncomfortable in the process. What I wanted to do is see if my stand-up would work in the country that most inspired it.

“They’re all Jewish,” Babette notes.

“Doug Stanhope and Richard Pryor aren’t,” I say, trying to steer the interview away from where I fear it is going. But it’s too late. Once again I am the Jewish comedian, asked to explain why Jews are so funny. It’s a topic that has come up in every interview since my career in the Netherlands began. Every time I explain that I don’t think being Jewish matters that much to who I am and that I am not so sure Jews are that much funnier. The way I see it, Jews being funny is a stereotype, one that’s only made more dangerous because so many Jews choose to believe in it themselves.

“When Israel bombs a village in Gaza, for example, you never hear how funny the Jews are,” I say, hoping to shock her a little. But Babette doesn’t let me get away that easily. She wants to know how I explain it, then, that there are so many good Jewish comedians. I reply that there are even more horrible Jewish comedians, but most people have never heard of them, precisely because they are so horrible. But that, she says, still does not explain why there are so many good Jewish comedians. Yes, I think, and those good Jewish comedians must be really tired of being asked whether it’s being a Jewish that made them funny.

“Maybe,” I say, “that’s why I came to New York—to experience what is feels like to be just a comedian, not the Jewish comedian people make me out to be in the Netherlands.”

“So, you did come to New York because you are a Jew,” Babette parries.

“Well,” I say, “if my comedy is about one thing it’s about being suspicious of people who claim they have an identity. When I was growing up in Maarn, a small village in the center of Holland, the only Jews I knew were my parents. Naturally, I thought that everything that set us apart from them could be attributed to our being Jews. So, when our neighbor had a fever blister, something I had never seen before, I was convinced it was not a very Jewish thing to walk around with.”

Only when my parents were on sabbatical and took us to live in New York did I realize that I had just as little in common with the Jewish children in my New York public school. It’s a lonely feeling to realize you have little in common with anybody. But when you accept it, it’s actually not that bad. You are, after all, not the only one who knows he is alone.

“So, is that the reason you called your show Amsterdam Abortion Survivor?” Babette asks.

“Yes,” I say, knowing full well that she actually never asked me this question, but for the purposes of this little story it’s just too good a question not to answer. “I just love the idea that Holland has this image as being such a liberal country. Just like Jews aren’t necessarily funny. The Dutch, actually, have quite a terrible track record when it comes to being open-minded. With the recent success of the Islamophobic populist politician Geert Wilders a new chapter of conservative bigotry was added to our country’s history. It’s one of the things I’ll be talking about in my New York show.

“And the ‘survivor’ bit?” Babette proceeds not to ask me.

“Well, if there is only one thing I find more dangerous than people choosing an ethnicity to hide behind, it’s the identity of victimhood. More and more people seem to define themselves as victims. It sometimes seems that to some people there even is a romantic side to being a Holocaust survivor. That to me is so obscene, it begs to be satirized.”

After the interview is over, I go back to my sublet to discover that five more tickets have been sold, bringing me to a grand total of 13.

To comfort myself I start reading Sarah Silverman’s hilarious new autobiography. I am elated to read that, just like me, she grew up in a town almost without Jews, she loves farts, and, just like me, owes her fame partly to a national controversy sparked by someone who refused to see a joke for what it was. “Wow,” I think while turning the pages, “if only Sarah would come to see my show.”

And then in the last chapter, Sarah tells the reader she is single! Sarah Single Silverman! By now I am sure we would hit it off right away. Why? Obviously we’re both Jewish.

Micha Wertheim’s one-man show, Amsterdam Abortion Survivor, is being performed as part of the New York International Fringe Festival, tonight through August 27.

Print Email

Daily rate: $2
Monthly rate: $18
Yearly rate: $180

Tablet is committed to bringing you the best, smartest, most enlightening and entertaining reporting and writing on Jewish life, all free of charge. We take pride in our community of readers, and are thrilled that you choose to engage with us in a way that is both thoughtful and thought-provoking. But the Internet, for all of its wonders, poses challenges to civilized and constructive discussion, allowing vocal—and, often, anonymous—minorities to drag it down with invective (and worse). Starting today, then, we are asking people who'd like to post comments on the site to pay a nominal fee—less a paywall than a gesture of your own commitment to the cause of great conversation. All proceeds go to helping us bring you the ambitious journalism that brought you here in the first place.

Readers can still interact with us free of charge via Facebook, Twitter, and our other social media channels, or write to us at Each week, we’ll select the best letters and publish them in a new letters to the editor feature on the Scroll.

We hope this new largely symbolic measure will help us create a more pleasant and cultivated environment for all of our readers, and, as always, we thank you deeply for your support.

David says:

niet komisch

Interesting angles. Interesting approaches. Not very funny.

A.L. Bell says:

There’s obviously no such thing as a “Jewish comedy” gene, but I think some Jewish people, and some non-Jewish people, have a “speak up” gene. We instinctively think we ought to speak up in class, write a letter to the editor, do standup comedy, write poetry or fiction, write newspaper articles, post to message board posts, etc. Maybe we figure out how to configure that trait in a socially acceptable way, so we repress it most of the time but then do standup comedy, but we always have the trait.

The people in my family who have this trait all seem to have a certain look. The people who don’t have that look don’t have that trait and are mortified by relatives’ tendency to spout off all the time.

So, in my opinion, the trait really exists and is probably a distant cousin of one of the genes involved with Asperger’s. People who have the speak up gene probably have above-average speaking and writing skills, a normal ability to feel emotions, a low average ability to read other people’s emotions in general, and a weak level of the ability to know when it’s time to shut up.

If people have this trait and don’t care too much whether other people are listening, it’s no big deal, but if people have the speak up trait and desperately want other people to pay attention, then you end up paying $3 for 5 minutes of open mike time, or with the essay that Daphne Merkin recently wrote about psychoanalysis for The New York Times Magazine.

RSchwartz says:

Very funny!

Would like to go!

Welcome to America!

Great fun.

Whoever doesn’t get the jokes is dense.

Thank you.

“the essay that Daphne Merkin recently wrote about psychoanalysis for The New York Times Magazine.”

allenby says:

NO, not funny at all. Very stupid actually.
I think Micha should be an actor, but not a stand up comedian. There are too many, and the best ones like Larry David, Richard Prior, Woody Allen, Jerry Seinfeld plus another maybe 100 Jewish exceptionally funny comedians…all of them are being copied by others, incl. Micha.
No my friend, go WEST!…or stay in NYC. The result might be the same.

I’m here thanks to my father’s decision not to get sterilized in Amsterdam in 1943 and my mother’s insistence that he’d become a professional artist (or she wouldn’t have wanted to give him a child) at age 50. Funny no? I can relate to an abortion survivor on more counts than one.

Taylor Shapiro says:

Great, refreshing and honest, Funny and so true!

Welcome to America!

Chloe Bornstein says:

certainly a different bend on things. some of the subjects are sad and not funny. this is not to say i don’t think he has the ability to entertain. the subject matter seems a bit off color and many might take offense. it’s hard to laugh at a person confined to a wheelchair, for example.

Larry says:

Chloe–Mel Brooks or Monty Python could do comedic wonders with a person confined to a wheelchair.
Think about it!
How about a contest between the two comics? Who can make it funnier?
Just start with a fart.

Washingtonian says:

Something must be lost in translation…. Must be funnier in Dutch from a Dutch cultural perspective… Not very funny here.

Un Juif Canadien says:

Sometimes the act comes off as a bit preachy, but it has funny moments too. I like the edginess.

In my limited experience of Amsterdam (4 days as a tourist) I was struck by the sometimes uneasy balance of Dutch austerity and openness. The best example was the bicycles. The most common type is Vermeer black and quite sturdy, but it is such a symbol of freedom (more so than the dope cafes and red light district). Nothing against dope cafes, I enjoyed them, and the red light district was simply dull. But those bicycles… To me they were the bloodstream of the city.

Good luck with your comedy.

I was hopeful to win a train ticket to ComorosBut will investigate to pop in this page when i am back.

Jack T. says:

Edgy, funny. Being Dutch is like being in the middle of a Calvinist anvil and Anarchist hammer. If they didn’t have Ann Frank they’d have to invent her, given their miserable record re: the Jews during the war.

vingerhoed says:

As a dutch person who has seen Micha’s shows in the Netherlands I like to add the following.
Micha is not just humor and simple joke’s. He make’s you feel uneasy and is on the edge of being funny or just plain offensive….

If you can’t handle, don’t go.

Godfreys is the name which does not need any recognition. Wertheim is a vacuum cleaner range from Godfreys and has various models or designs to suit every individual specifications. The brand of vacuum cleaners is liked by Canadians the most and they love to own a Wertheim pool vacuum cleaner. You will find many of positive reviews about self powered crawlers by Wertheim that would clean your pool overnight without no manual intervention. Just select the type of vacuum cleaner that would be appropriate for you + enjoy the quality of a wertheim vacuum cleaners

A good place to hunt newest things! Good job.

Thanks for your website, it is very good. I found the information that I need and I will come back. Best Christmas Gift Ideas

I’ve said that least 4288059 times. The problem this like that is they are just too compilcated for the average bird, if you know what I mean

Normally I wouldn’t comment on posts but I felt that I had to as your writing style is definitely good. You have broken down a difficult area so that it easy to understand. I consider that you would enjoy reading what another good blogger has to say on the topic.


Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words. HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment. We reserve the right to delete inappropriate comments.

Thank You!

Thank you for subscribing to the Tablet Magazine Daily Digest.
Please tell us about you.

Dutch Treat

On the eve of his New York debut, an Amsterdam comedian reflects on Jewish funniness, the liberalism of the Netherlands, and Sarah Silverman. Plus a video preview.

More on Tablet:

Cruelty & Perversity: Postprandial Reflections on the PEN Protesters

By Paul Berman — The grim satire of the ‘Charlie Hebdo’ controversy, in context